Make a smart decision, Illinois

In the governor's race in Illinois, just the fact that he's Republican is sufficient that I would discourage you from voting for Bill Brady. There's also this video in which he claims to believe in both creation and evolution, but I have to say I found the interviewer more annoying than the wanna-be governor.

There's a point where he's hectoring Brady, telling him there are only two sides, he's either got to be in favor of some garbled version of young earth creationism/intelligent design creationism, or he's in favor of evolution. The interviewer insists on this despite Brady stating that he's a theistic evolutionist, that his god created the world and evolution was the tool that he used to create humans.

It's a very silly notion, but it's still a real and commonly held position that is not synonymous with fundamentalist Biblical literalism. It's wrong, but you aren't going to show that it's wrong by falsely pigeonholing a proponent into another, wronger position. It was very annoying to listen to someone who didn't understand creationism trying to use his ignorance to bludgeon the dope.

So please do vote against Bill Brady. But do so for the right reasons, OK?

Tags

More like this

P.Z. Myers does not agree with my take on Mitt Romney's statement regarding evolution. Now, I agree with P.Z. on about 99% of everything in life. But on this one, and on theistic evolution generally, he is way off. Let's start with his title: “Mitt Romney, theistic evolutionist...and this is…
Orson Scott Card has written a long essay defending Intelligent Design. Oy, but it is depressing. It's a graceless hash, a cluttered and confusing mish-mash of poorly organized complaints about those darned wicked "Darwinists". He lists 7 arguments. Then he repeats his list, expanding on them.…
I just received this dispatch from Monica Metzler, President of the Illinois Science Council. This is important. The current leading candidate in the Illinois Governor's race has acknowledged his belief in intelligent design and his willingness to permit individual school districts to allow it to…
As I hear people debate about evolution and religion, I feel like I'm listening to a political debate between two middle schoolers. One says that you have to vote republican because taxes are bad and the other says no, democrats are right because the republican kid has cooties. No one seems to…