Bush, the Vatican & stem cells- what's really behind the policy?

The Daily Telegraph today reported that "Scientists who carry out embryonic stem cell research and politicians who pass laws permitting the practice will be excommunicated." Does this policy make rational sense, even on religion's own terms?

Here's more from the article:

Scientists who carry out embryonic stem cell research and politicians who pass laws permitting the practice will be excommunicated, the Vatican said yesterday. "Destroying human embryos is equivalent to an abortion. It is the same thing," said Cardinal Alfonso Lopez Trujillo, head of the Pontifical Council for the Family. "Excommunication will be applied to the women, doctors and researchers who eliminate embryos [and to the] politicians that approve the law," he said in an interview with / Famiglia Christiana/, an official Vatican magazine.

Last fall I attended a panel that Seed's Chris Mooney was on, at which Ronald Bailey of the Reason Foundation made the point that something like 80% of fertilized embryos don't implant, and exit naturally during the next menstrual cycle.

Bailey made the remark that it's amazing that politicians and religious extremists hold embryos in such high regard when God Himself throws away 80% of them. To me, policies such as this just show that the interest of religionists and some politicians in criminalizing abortion is more about perpetuating patriarchy than anything else.

Tags

More like this

From The Daily Telegraph: Scientists who carry out embryonic stem cell research and politicians who pass laws permitting the practice will be excommunicated, the Vatican said yesterday. "Destroying human embryos is equivalent to an abortion. It is the same thing," said Cardinal Alfonso Lopez…
The ultra right US House of Representatives has voted to lift some restrictions on embryonic stem cell research and the Senate will likely follow suit, maybe as soon as today (New Scientist). The bill effectively zeroes out a five year ban on federal financing of stem cell research by allowing…
I suppose this is a kind of threat—an archaic and quaint threat, but I'm sure some people take it seriously—but the Catholic church has made a strong statement against embryonic stem cell research. The Vatican stepped up its fight against embryonic stem cell research on Wednesday, saying that…
Man, I've been picking on the Vatican a lot lately. Don't worry, I'll abuse all other religions later (I'm thoroughly impartial), but it's just that the Catholic church has been doing such stupid things. Like this: A Vatican official has said the Catholic church will excommunicate a medical team…