Goodbye to MSHA's Stickler

Yesterday afternoon, if you happened to MSHA's website and click on the Asst. Secretary's button, you'd see this, with the ominous caption:

"The page you are looking for might have been removed, had its name changed, or is temporarily unavailable."

That was a tell-tale sign that Richard Stickler's recess-appointment tenure as MSHA's chief has come to an end.  Ken Ward of The Charleston Gazette reports today in "Stickler out at MSHA" that a political appointee named John Pallasch is now the acting Assistant Secretary for MSHA.

Ward reports:

"...on Thursday, MSHA officials revealed that agency staffer John Pallasch had been named to Sticklerâs job...on an acting basis.  Previously, Pallasch had been a deputy assistant labor secretary handling policy matters for MSHA. Before that, he was a special assistant in MSHAâs administration unit, and worked for the labor departmentâs Office of Assistant Secretary for Administration and Management."

Some readers of The Pump Handle may recall that MSHA had an "acting" assistant secretary for nearly two years, when Mr. David Dye served for Secretary Elaine Chao as the mine safety chief.  Mr. Dye was in charge of MSHA from November 2004, during the Sago disaster, and until October 2006.  He may be best remembered for walking out of a Senate hearing convened by Senator Arlen Specter (R-PA) about the Sago tragedy which claimed 12 miners' lives on January 2, 2006. 

Information about this newest "acting" MSHA chief is hard to come by, although Ken Ward tried to pry something out of Administration officials:

"...itâs not clear how long Pallasch will be running the $340 million agency or if President Bush plans to submit a different nominee to Congress.  Amy Louviere, an MSHA spokeswoman, declined to answer such questions. Louviere referred a reporter to David James, the top spokesman for Labor Secretary Elaine Chao.  James did not return repeated phone calls. In an e-mail message, James did not elaborate on what Chaoâs plans are for MSHA leadership through the rest of Bushâs term."

Hmmph.  I feel a little schnookered----just yesterday I wrote favorably about Stickler's $220,000 penalty issued on Dec. 28 to a mine operator for flagrantly violating lockout/tagout rules.

"Perhaps the higher-ups in Secretary Elaine Chaoâs office and at the White House will be busy this year stumping for their favorite GOP presidential candidates that theyâll leave Mr. Stickler alone to do the apolitical work of enforcing mine safety laws.  Heâs off to a good start announcing this penalty against TECO Energyâs  (NYSE: TE) Perry Coal Mine."

I also tried to make the case for keeping Stickler on-board at MSHA in a Dec. 14 post âMSHAâs Stickler: Will he stay or will he go?â.

âTo his credit, Mr. Stickler has made a lot of commitments over the last few months to straighten things out at the agency.  Heâs instituted a program to put âbad-actorâ mine operators on notice (i.e.,pattern of violations), he established an office of accountability and the 100 percent plan to ensure all inspections are completed.  Perhaps heâs also learned some harsh lessons about his agencyâs culture and the performance of his top staff.  The learning curve is steeper than most people realize.  With only one year left in the G.W. Bush Administration, it would be wise to keep Mr. Stickler on board at MSHA.  We should expect that heâs learned from his mistakes and demand that he make good on his promises.â  

I'm 0-100 on guessing what Secretary Chao and the White House will do when it comes to protecting workers' health and safety.

More like this

As the year is winding down, one question on the minds of many MSHA inspectors, managers and staff has to be: Will Stickler be here in 2008?  The MSHA chief, Richard Stickler, received his job from President G.W. Bush on a "recess appointment," which expires at the end of the current U.S.…
by Tom Bethell (Posted with permission from The Mountain Eagle, Whitesburg, KY) Just when you think youâve seen it all, somebody in the Bush administration comes up with another way to compromise somebody elseâs rights. The latest example is Richard Stickler, director of the Mine Safety and Health…
A coal mine operator in Hazard, Kentucky received a $220,000 penalty from MSHA for flagrantly violating electrical lockout/tagout procedures (such as padlocking an on/off switch to ensure that a machine is not unexpectedly turned-on, plugged in or energized while it is being serviced.)  The…
Imagine being an MSHA inspector and being asked by independent investigators for your honest and frank opinion about the events surrounding the August 2007 disaster at the Crandall Canyon mine, which took the lives of nine men.  You decide to participate because you genuinely believe in MSHA's…