Injury incident alerts: blaming worker is not a safety lesson

The Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) deserves credit for rapidly publicizing information about serious injury incidents and close call events. A brief recap and single photo make an easy lesson for a pre-shift safety meeting or toolbox talk. But MSHA needs to reject language in its safety alerts that blames workers for their injuries. It's an easy trap to fall into, but it's not effective for injury prevention.

This morning, an MSHA "Serious Incident Alert" landed in my inbox.  The lead sentences read:

"A miner was trying to determine why clay was not flowing properly by examining a chute that discharged into a screw conveyor. Instead of using a ladder to look inside, he stood on top of the metal screw conveyor cover his foot slipped and he fell approximately three feet to the grating floor hitting his head and suffered serious injuries."

The phrase "instead of using a ladder" points blame directly on the miner. It dilutes the safety lesson because MSHA describes the incident as the worker's fault. It reinforces the superficial approach to occupational safety which insists that workers are responsible for their injuries. More crudely, "if workers didn't do dumb things, they wouldn't get injured."

I know this miner did not intend to suffer an injury. I can put myself in his shoes. He was focused on figuring out the problem. The clogged shut was probably slowing down the task at hand. He wanted to keep the process moving along. Getting a ladder would delay things. Where the heck is a ladder? We've all been there.

I've no doubt this seriously injured worker's thoughts were well-intentioned. His is just the kind of stick-to-it-ness that employers define as a "good worker." Until something goes wrong, and the "good worker" becomes the one that gets blamed for his injury.

We don't need a government agency legitimizing a safety approach that blames workers. It misses the chance for a safety lesson to get to the root problem.

 

More like this

After 35 years of service, Mr. Sherman Lynn Holmes, 55, retired from the Pine River School District. Before long though, he gave up the life of a retiree to work as a woodsman. It was his true calling and lifelong passion. He knew the woods and trees of northern Michigan like the back of his hand…
Motivational speaker Kina Repp shares a dramatic story when she addresses audiences at occupational health and safety conferences. In 1990, Repp lost her arm in a piece of machinery when she was working at a seafood canning plant in Alaska. She was a college student trying to earn money for college…
Nurses and other healthcare workers joined Members of Congress yesterday at a news conference to discuss violence on the job in the healthcare industry. Ms. Helene Andrews, RN recalled being assaulted by a 25 year old psychiatric patient at Danbury Hospital. She was handing him mediation and a…
If you want to keep all your digits and limbs, you probably want to avoid working at Anheuser-Busch's Metal Container Corp., in Arnold, Missouri. That worksite was recently cited by OSHA for hazards related to incidents last fall in which one worker lost fingers in machinery, and another worker…