I'm bothered by odd redundancy in an 80s song lyric. Millas mirakel advises us that "It is better to light the fire of life than to never be allowed to be yourself". Yes, and? That turn of phrase should compare two undesirable things, like "It is better to lose one toe than to lose both eyes." Here Milla, who I might add is overall a strangely schoolmasterly and archaic pop lyricist, is basically saying "It is better to win the lottery than to lose both eyes."
This is why we shouldn't have freedom of speech.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
More politics, sorry. Still, if you want science, RC and J+J are blogging AGU. But CIP is delighted with Obama's speech on the economy. I'm less so; the comment there from Wolfgang (He always gave great speeches... this was one reason he won in 2008. The problem is that great speeches are not…
In which I list some pop song lyrics for you to guess, because it's Friday and I'm tired.
------------
The other night, on Twitter, Patrick Nielsen Hayden posted a snippet of song lyrics with the hashtag "#greatestalbumsofalltime." I was bored and looking to kill time, so I followed up with a…
Some recent Facebook updates of mine:
After four years' living in this house I just stubbed my toe on the bathrooom threshold for the first time -- painfully. Unusually, I was wearing semi-industrial hearing protectors on my way to the john -- because also unusually two people were watching TV at…
In case you somehow missed it: tech writer and blogger Kathy Sierra canceled public appearances after receiving death threats. In addition to the death threats, she called attention to some posts about her that were threatening in tone (though probably falling short of actual threats) and…
I only hear stuff similar to what my little sister listened to. Ok, that´s forbiden :)
If they don't understand semantics, that's no reason to deny them free speech :)
Looking for signs of intelligent life in pop lyrics?
I imagine the lighting of the fire of life to involve the burning of bridges to a certain extent, i e "better to risk something than playing it safe". Quite the unepected exegesis, btw.
Yes, that's a reasonable interpretation of what the lyricist was trying to say.
Somebody has to take these people to task, you know.
Isn't the saying, often attributed to Eleanor Roosevelt, at least by my mom, "It is better to light a candle than to curse the darkness." The comparison there is between a favorable and unfavorable thing. I think the "it is better" construct is asymmetric, but otherwise neutral, neither supporting nor contrasting. (I've been doing some SAT tutoring, so I've been analyzing a lot of sentences lately.)
Apparently, the saying is a motto of the Christophers (http://www.christophers.org/page.aspx?pid=266), but was used by Adlai Stevenson at Eleanor Roosevelt's funeral. That probably explains my mother's association.