"They are moblized, focussed, and driven to succeed"

There's some psychological/political/sociological phenomenon, I can't remember what it's called, in which you tend to think of yourself and your allies as a diverse coalition, while thinking of the people on the other side as a monolithic bloc. I was thinking about this when I read this comment by Jeffrey Toobin:

The President is pro-choice . . . But, like many modern pro-choice Democrats, he has worked so hard to be respectful of his opponents on this issue that he sometimes seems to cede them the moral high ground. In his book "The Audacity of Hope," he describes the "undeniably difficult issue of abortion" and ponders "the middle-aged feminist who still mourns her abortion." Elsewhere, he announces, "Abortion vexes." The opponents of abortion aren't vexed--they are mobilized, focussed, and driven to succeed. The Catholic bishops took the lead in pushing for the Stupak amendment, and they squeezed legislators in a way that would do any K Street lobbyist proud. . . .

Toobin might be right about the Catholic bishops, but more generally it seems to me that the opponents of abortion are very divided. I still remember when abortion-opponent Dan Quayle, when asked what he would do if his daughter decided to have an abortion, that he would "support her on whatever decision she made."

Maybe Toobin is on to something regarding current political tactics, though. It would be interesting to see how this could be studied, ideally looking at many issues, not just abortion. Perhaps abortion opponents appear more monolithic because abortion is legal, so they can oppose it at the margins without having to agree on the next steps.

More like this

Hilzoy and Megan McArdle have had an exchange over abortion, which includes, as these discussions always do, a ton of talking-past-each-other. This tends to happen, because anti-choicers tend to ignore the pregnant woman, and put all their attention on the well-being of the embryo (and my friend…
When I return from the ASM2011 meeting, I hope to discuss this excellent post by Michael Bérubé about the political centrality of the culture wars. Until then, I'll leave you with the post from the archives, "Abortion Is a Blessing": Abortion isn't the lesser of two evils--it is a just and good…
Abortion isn't the lesser of two evils--it is a just and good thing. So says Reverend Katherine Ragsdale: Let's be very clear about this: when a woman finds herself pregnant due to violence and chooses an abortion, it is the violence that is the tragedy; the abortion is a blessing. When a woman…
Congressman Bart Stupak has helped tank the Medicare +5% reimbursement plan and single payer (italics mine): The problem with an amendment strategy [for Medicare +5% and single-payer] is that the House leadership will likely not allow many, if any, amendments to be offered on the House floor. The…