Global Warming and Rockfalls

Over at The Island of Doubt, James Hrynyshyn has a brief post up about this Guardian article. The article in the Guardian discusses a large rockfall that is expected to happen in the next few days - about two million cubic meters of Mt. Eiger in the Swiss Alps are expected to take a short, quick trip down. The Guardian reports that a scientist monitoring the situation calls it an indirect result of global warming. James correctly notes that the article provides no explanation of why this might be the case, so I thought I would.

Increased erosion rates probably aren't the first thing that pops to mind as a result of climate change, but it's actually a very reasonable expectation. A major cause of erosion in areas where there are cold winters is the freeze-thaw cycle. Water is pretty good at getting into cracks in rock, and other such confined places. Water also, as you are probably aware, expands when it freezes. When water freezes in cracks in the rock, it acts like a wedge, forcing the cracks wider. When the ice melts, the crack can hold more water, and the next time it freezes, the water will expand again and force the crack wider still. Given enough time, and enough freeze-thaw cycles, rock will break as a result. That's pretty basic and non-controversial science, and it was probably covered when you took science in high school.

Now for the global warming tie-in. As temperatures rise, there are going to be places that see more freeze-thaw cycles per year than they did in the past. In colder times, they might have gone through only a few cycles per year, because the temperatures remained below freezing for the vast majority of the winter - remember, it's the repeated action of freezing and thawing that causes the erosion. Once the water has frozen, the damage has been done for that cycle, and you need to thaw and re-freeze to work the cracks wider. If the climate is such that the temperature only climbs above freezing two or three times a year, then the rocks will only go through two or three freeze-thaw cycles per year. In places like that, a little bit of warming can have a huge effect.

In terms of the overall climate, an increase in warming that results in temperatures climbing over the freezing point ten or twelve times in a year, instead of the three or four that was common in the past, really isn't much of a change. In terms of the number of freeze-thaw cycles, it's an enormous increase. I expect that this is what's happening in the Swiss Alps, and that this is why lots of rock is soon going to be coming down that mountain.

More like this

I enjoy most any mix of science and mountaineering — part of why I so like Mark Bowen's Thin Ice, his book about climatologist Lonnie Thompson's remarkable work documenting global warming in high-altitude glaciers. Scientific work done at rarefied altitudes. How can you not like it? The North…
Climate change has been blamed for a lot of things, sometimes not entirely based on the scientific evidence. But this is a first, at least to me: From today's Guardian: A vast chunk of Europe's most ill-famed mountain threatens to break loose and crash down in the next few days, a geologist…
Over the past few days, as I've suffered through home repairs, caring for a sick child, and a bit of writer's block, I've been contemplating the power of one of our most basic resources: water. We tend to take this simple fluid for granted, barely noticing it sitting in a glass on a restaurant…
One of the things I love about geology is the jargon. After all, what could possibly be more fun than laying down "clayey" or "vug" on a triple word score and being able to say that yes, it is too a word? Wait, don't answer that one. Instead, let me give you one of my favorite passages from Basin…

So do you advise against investing in a cabin nestled at the foot of the Sierras/Rockies/Alps?

By R A VARGA (not verified) on 09 Jul 2006 #permalink

Hmm, that makes a bit more sense.

When I first saw this one, I didn't buy it - I thought it falls into the classic fallacy of trying to attribute a specific weather event to GW - it doesn't work that way, since GW refers to a large scale statistical effect, instead of specific cases.

However, putting this erosion issue as the cause of changed climates...

Its probably not a matter of freeze thaw, but rather of thaw of
shear zones. If the average surface temperature changes from just
below freezing to just above, then gradually the ground will thaw from
the surface inwards. A thawed shearzone is more likely to fail then a frozen one.
Or perhaps the mechanism is deeper penetration of meltwater, due to
either gradually warming temperature, or loss of surface ice.
Of course these are only guesses, I don't know what the author
was really thinking, but they are plausable.

By ownwingate (not verified) on 10 Jul 2006 #permalink

Plausible, yes. Without the statistics to show the probability that a particular event is caused by anthorpogenic climate change, however, I wouldn't go out on a limb and make the attribution.

In the case of this particular rockfall, the global warming tie-in is that the glacier that has been holding it up has retreated -- it's got nothing to do with the change in the freeze-thaw cycle.

From http://www.ifyouski.com/news/newsarticle/?ObjectID=7749515

[...] the crack has been caused by the retreat of the Grindelwald glacier, which previously supported the rockface. As it has shrunk, holes in the limestone have opened and been eroded by water. [Hans-Rudolf Keusen, who monitors the Bernese Alps for the Swiss government] said: "In the past 25 years the glacier has regressed very quickly, by up to a metre a year. We believe this accelerated regression is the result of climate change. Without the support of the glacier, small fissures have opened in the rock which have widened significantly. This is happening very fast, and the rock could fall within days."

By John Atkinson (not verified) on 12 Jul 2006 #permalink

Would someone mind explaining to me how a higher temperate will cause more Freeze thaw cycles to happen?
Thanks.

By Anonymous (not verified) on 07 Feb 2008 #permalink