Bloggasm survey of diversity in the blogosphere

Simon Owens has posted the results of his survey of diversity in the blogosphere at his site Bloggasm.

Here are the results for the blogosphere as a whole:

Male: 69%
Female: 31%
***
White/Caucasian/European: 73%
Black/African: 9%
Asian: 10%
Middle Eastern/Arab: 1%
Latino/Hispanic: 6%
Native American: 1%

This seems about right to me, based on anecdotal experience. Simon also broke down his results by niche. Here are the findings for science blogs (which presumably includes CogDaily's response):

Male: 71%
Female: 29%
***
White/Caucasian/European: 88%
Black/African: 6%
Asian: 6%

One thing I find interesting about this result is the low number of Asians who science blog -- lower even than the blogosphere as a whole. It's possible that the sample size of science blogs was too small to get a reliable result, but I'd have to say that my personal experience bears this out as well. We know there are lots of Asian scientists; where are the Asian science bloggers?

Also, it appears from Simon's sample that women are over-represented among science bloggers: 29 percent, compared to "about one fifth" of the science workforce, according to the recent NAS report.

I do have some questions about Simon's methodology: how were the 1,000 blogs for the study selected? Clearly he didn't just select the Technorati top 1,000 -- we wouldn't have made the cut then. Was an effort made to capture the "long tail" of the blogosphere -- those millions of less popular blogs that make up the vast majority of blogs overall? And what was the response rate? Is it possible that diversity was over- or under-represented because of this?

That said, the study is an impressive accomplishment, certainly the most thorough accounting of diversity of blogosphere that I've seen. I'd add only one point, which I made in my survey response as well: the sheer size of the blogosphere allows anyone to have a diverse experience, whether or not this experience reflects the diversity of the blogosphere as a whole. Even if there are relatively few women science bloggers, I can choose to read proportionately more of them. My experience of the blogosphere doesn't have to be the same as the blogosphere's actual composition.

Tags

More like this

Simon Owens of Bloggasm has conducted an unscientific survey of diversity in the blogosphere by emailing a bunch of bloggers to ask them demographic questions. He emailed 1,000 bloggers, and on that basis, has constructed a quick profile of the "blogosphere": Male: 69% Female: 31% *** White/…
The other day, Coturnix alluded to Simon Owens of Bloggasm and his survey of blogosphere diversity. I neglected to note that I was one of the respondents. Simon's questions were: 1. What niche does your blog fall into (Examples: Political, gadget, movie, etc...If more than one, please list)? 2.…
Small kerfuffle about the fact that ScienceBlogsTM is so white. Some amusement that I am one of the white science bloggers. In any case, this comment caught my attention: Second, it is no secret that minorities of most stripes are seriously underrepresented in science. Bloggers are even more…
Tim left this comment over at Uncertain Principles on Chad's post The Pipeline Problem: I thought the data was pretty clear about this: past high school, the [physics] pipeline is no more leaky for women than it is for men...here's the Report: Read it for yourselves. Examination of the academic "…