Friday Fun: Recreation of Infamous Bridge Collapse Exonerates Engineers

Thanks be to the Flying Spaghetti Monster for the Cronk of Higher Ed. That is all.

Recreation of Infamous Bridge Collapse Exonerates Engineers

Researchers at the U.S. Marine Academy's civil engineering labs have determined that the designers of the original Tacoma Narrows Bridge were not responsible for that structure's spectacular 1940 collapse.

"It's those videos," commented Dr. Ramsey Archer, head of the research team. "Millions of people have seen footage of the bridge's gyrating plunge over and over again, ad nauseam. Very cool to watch, but it's lousy science."

Dr. Ramsey's idea was to have cadets, as the Marine Academy's students are known, build a 1/200th scale replica of the bridge and reproduce the winds that destroyed it.

*snip*

The research team did not offer any firm theories as to what caused the original bridge's demise.

"Maybe terrorism," said Capt. Hale Vessel, associate chair of the Marine Academy's civil engineering department. "Or maybe the paint they used corroded the cables. Who the heck knows? Anyway, at least nobody died. Though it is a shame about that little dog."

Students participating in the study received credit for a senior practicum in structural mechanics, a course colloquially known as "Hoist and Duck."

"It was a great opportunity," commented one of the students. "And almost as much fun as blowing things up."

Tags

More like this

"At least six lamp posts were snapped off while I watched. A few minutes later, I saw a side girder bulge out. But, though the bridge was bucking up at an angle of 45 degrees, I thought she would be able to fight it out. But, that wasn't to be." -Bert Farquharson If you’ve only ever seen one bridge…
The American Scientist is the magazine of the scientific society, Sigma Xi. You can get it on the news stand, and that's where I bought the latest issue (March-April, 2009). One of the articles is by historian of engineering, Henry Petroski, and it's about the Tacoma Narrows Bridge. The bridge was…
Yeah, we've all had this kind of week. Thanks to The Cronk for humourously saving my soul this week: University Performs Fastest Soulectomy on Record. Doctors have finally verified claims that the College of Madison performed the fastest soulectomy in higher education history. "We couldn't believe…
tags: NYC Life, Brooklyn Bridge, Emily Roebling, NYC history I have been watching the superb series of DVDs called New York, thanks to one of my currently vacationing pet sitting clients who owns it (now I wish to own this series too, so I can watch it over and over again). Because of this series,…

What a bizarre conclusion. Every physics student has seen that famous video, and it is pretty clear that no bridge should move that way. Even if it hadn't collapsed, the video demonstrates that the bridge was improperly designed.

Also, just because the mock-up didn't collapse in the wind tunnel doesn't mean anything, given the difficulties of making accurate 1/200 scale girders exactly analogous to the real ones (including 1/200 scale rivets or welds).

Is the "terrorism" explanation a joke? Or is our military that far removed from reality? Terrorists back then sent a strong wind to do their dirty work????

Lou,

I take it you are not familiar with "The Cronk" and the work it does. Go forth and peruse their website, and then you will understand.

No need to thank me. The sound of your facepalm when you finally get it will be its own reward!

By Amenhotepstein (not verified) on 23 Dec 2011 #permalink

Thanks!!! I had no idea. I don't live in the US anymore and wasn't familiar with the Cronk.

The sad thing is that nowadays the real news that comes out of the US is often indistinguishable from satire.