Commuting and Adaptation

When I lived in London, I used to have to take the bus to Oxford. Without traffic, the ride took 70 minutes, which was just long enough to catch up on my reading and iPOD playlists. But as anyone who knows the M40 will tell you, there is almost always traffic. As a result, I never adjusted to the annoyance of commuting. While I would happily tolerate the 70 minute bus ride - this was my baseline - I would get furious at the fender-bender that made my ride home take twice as long. Commuting was a continual crapshoot, and it drove me crazy.

This is one of the more important and ignored facts of psychology. While people can adapt to just about anything - our nervous systems are adept at habituation - we can't adapt to unpredictable situations. The morning traffic is one of those situations. Unlike chronic pain, which eventually becomes less painful, commuting remains a constant pain-in-the-ass. Nevertheless, people want their 3.5 bedrooms in suburbia, and are willing to live in the middle of nowhere to get it. We are quickly becoming a nation of extreme commuters. From the WSJ:

A report released yesterday by the National Research Council's Transportation Research Board looking at U.S. commuting patterns from 1990 to 2004 found that more commuters are leaving for work before and after the traditional peak hours of 6 a.m. to 9 a.m. In addition, the report found that the off-peak group gained about half of all new commuters from 1990 to 2000. In particular, commuters starting their journey to work between 5 a.m. to 6:30 a.m. gained about 25% of the growth in commuters, and those leaving between 9 a.m. and 11 a.m. gained more than 12% of all new commuters.

Much of modern psychology doesn't have direct application to daily life. But the old truth of sensory adaption is a profoundly relevant fact. We will habituate to the bigger home, and the nice front lawn. We will even adapt to that big screen HDTV. After a little while, we will start taking these material pleasures for granted, and they will stop giving us joy. But the pain of commuting will remain. If you want to make yourself happier, walk to work.

i-4db6624f3f206b8d569b5bdc20d119bb-picture.bmp

More like this

If people were rational creatures, you might expect them to respond to rising gas prices by doing less solitary commuting. The cost of filling up the tank would provide an incentive to either carpool or use a heavily subsidized mass transit system. But that hasn't happened: Despite high gasoline…
David Brooks, summarizing the current state of happiness research: The daily activity most injurious to happiness is commuting. According to one study, being married produces a psychic gain equivalent to more than $100,000 a year. In other words, the best way to make yourself happy is to have a…
I've always been fascinated by traffic. (I grew up in LA, so I had plenty of time to indulge my interest.) City streets are a complex system in which seemingly insignificant changes - a broken street light, a stalled car, a poorly designed highway merge - can have dramatic consequences. In this…
In 2003, the city of London took a dramatic step in the battle against traffic congestion: It implemented a congestion charge of £5 for those driving private vehicles into an eight-square-mile central congestion zone on weekdays between 7am and 6:30pm. The fees were increased twice, and since 2011…

For ten years I commuted by car, train and tram, for two hours each way. I did a PhD on the train, effectively. At the end of it I was buggered, but.

I really can't complain as my commute is 20 minutes and it is a straight shot on 1 bus line. The bus ride is fine even if it takes 30 minutes. It is the people on the bus that annoy me - they smell, their iPods are so loud, they push (or fall as the bus lurches) ... I didn't work for 6 years so I didn't have to deal with a daily commute. 3 months of working and I still have not adjusted.