The Wii and Obesity

Last week, I wrote about how the Nintendo Wii is the first emotional video game system, since it forces your body to become involved in playing the game. (Fans of Wiliam James and Antonio Damasio will know what I'm talking about: all of our feelings actually begin in the flesh.)

But now it turns out that all this Wii exercise has some negative consequences. Video game fanatics are really out of shape, and aren't used to getting off the couch:

The new console has been wildly successful, selling out at stores and winning high marks from critics and game buffs. But as players spend more time with the Wii, some are noticing that hours waving the game's controller around can add up to fairly intense exertion -- resulting in aches and pains common in more familiar forms of exercise. They're reporting aching backs, sore shoulders -- even something some have dubbed "Wii elbow."

"It's harder than playing basketball," says Kaitlin Franke, a 12-year-old from Louisville, Ky. She has been camped out in front of her family's TV, fine-tuning her bowling motion and practicing boxing footwork in two of the Wii's games. Almost immediately, she says, her right arm started to feel numb.

Her arm is numb? Is this poor kid having a stroke? And is the Wii the cure for childhood obesity? It's about time Generation Z exercises something besides their thumbs.


More like this

Ever since Pac Man, video games have obeyed a few basic principles: A player sits down in front of a screen and presses a few buttons with his or her thumbs. Perhaps there's a joystick involved, or maybe the index finger has to do some work, too. But the body is essentially still. The only moving…
The epic battle between video game consoles seems to have a clear winner: the Nintendo Wii. The Wii, which uses an innovative wireless controller to translate the players' motions onto the screen, has upset the order of the video game world. In electronics stores and elsewhere, there are growing…
Today at the SCQ, we've put up a journal club entry (i.e. full citation details and you can also get the pdf of the first page of the article at that link). It's kind of an obvious one, which simply shows data whereby you're more likely to exert energy when playing Nintendo Wii vs the XBOX (which…
I've got a short essay on the Nintendo Wii, William James and Antonio Damasio over at It's fun for the whole family. (And don't believe the Sony Playstation 3 hype, unless you really care about how realistically your basketball players sweat. The Wii is a much cooler system.) This…

I understand why it might be a more emotional game system, but saying that other games can't affect your emotions (which is what "first emotional game system" suggests to me) is silly.

You're right, although I do think the Wii is emotional in a very different way than other thumb-centric consoles.

I agree with you about that these kids need to exercise something besides their thumbs. I find the whole thing about the Wii being a good source of exercise, kind of silly. I understand that we have this whole generation of gamers but how can this realy compare to real exercise or even just going outside and playing. While I myself find these games fun and amusing I do not see them as a good source of exercise. Whatever happened to the good 'ol days of going and playing basketball, football, hockey or whatever your choice of game was in the street of your neighborhood. I see the wii as another excuse for our obese children to stay inside instead of going outside and playing. They are missing out on all the fun that my friends and I, as well as many others use to have. As far as being involved emotionally involved in the games as well I think that many of them really need to get a life and go experience something that is real and not hooked up to a TV.

Her arm is numb? Is this poor kid having a stroke?

Are you actually surprised that kids will play video games to the point of numbness?
I grew up when the NES and SNES were popular. I didn't know any owner of NES or SNES that didn't play at least a few games to the point of numbness (of hands and fingers, usually). I would not expect the fact that many Wii games require the user to stand up, and move their feet and arms to change this.