Science Goes YouTube

This is a briliant idea: Youtube for test tubes. Instead of trying to translate the methodology of experiments into technical prose, why not just videotape the experiments? Most of the time, science is just a fancy form of manual labor, and as most researchers can tell you, trying to replicate a lab experiment is often an exercise in hermeneutics. So why not just show people exactly how it's done?

Cemile Guldal pays attention to details. Her tattoo of a DNA double-helix, for example, doesn't wrap quite all the way around her right arm because doing so would have distorted the major and minor grooves of the helix. And that simply wouldn't do.

So when Guldal, a graduate student at Princeton University in New Jersey, began studying how well different yeast strains invade the medium on which they are growing, she followed the protocols to the letter. But no matter how many times she repeated the experiment, she couldn't produce the results that she saw in published papers.

"For about a year, my boss thought I was completely incompetent because I couldn't replicate those beautiful published pictures," says Guldal. Later, she realized that her troubles stemmed from a basic misunderstanding about how the experiment was performed -- she had been scrubbing the surface yeast cells from her medium, instead of simply washing it under running water.

Guldal's struggles are precisely what the newly launched Journal of Visualized Experiments (JoVE) strives to stamp out. The fledgling online journal, which started up this month, consists entirely of videos of scientists performing basic molecular-biology protocols.

The journal is the pet project of Moshe Pritsker, a postdoctoral researcher at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. Pritsker hopes that JoVE will help scientists to improve the reproducibility of their work, while also providing a window for the public to view what goes on in the lab.

Tags

More like this

Anyone who has tried to replicate an experiment based on the description published in a paper knows that this can be difficult, frustrating, and often close to impossible. The protocols in the Methods section can be incomplete, even inaccurate, and sometimes lead the hopeful reader down a trail of…
Have you ever read a paper in your field and wondered "how'd they done it?!" You read the "Materials and Methods" closely, again and again, and still have no idea how exactly was the procedure done. You want to replicate the experiment, or use the same technique for your own questions, but have no…
Moshe Pritsker and I first met at Scifoo, then shared a panel at the Harvard Millennium Confreence and finally met again at the Science Blogging Conference two weeks ago. Moshe is the Editor-in-Chief of Journal of Visualized Experiments, the innovative online journals that publishes videos…
Most scientists I know get a chuckle out of the Journal of Irreproducible Results (JIR), a humor journal that often parodies scientific papers. Back in the day, we used to chuckle at articles like "Any Eye for an Eye for an Arm and a Leg: Applied Dysfunctional Measurement" and "A Double Blind…

Darn, I was looking for a video on the technique of supercritical CO2 drying of alcogels.

By ERIC JUVE (not verified) on 28 Nov 2006 #permalink

The ES thawing video shows the tech going into a liquid nitrogen tank with latex gloves and no eye protection.. of course we all did that back in the day... but I hope her safety officer doesn't see it.

It's a very good and very simple idea. But I think I can predict one of its effects: The most glamourous lab assistants will be the ones asked to demonstrate the protocols.

"That was great the way you set up the refluxing chamber, Lola, but could you do it again, this time with more lipstick?" ;-)