1. cortex
  2. Neuroscience and Free Will

Neuroscience and Free Will

By cortex on December 20, 2006.

The Economist believes that "modern neuroscience is eroding the idea of free will":

In the late 1990s a previously blameless American began collecting child pornography and propositioning children. On the day before he was due to be sentenced to prison for his crimes, he had his brain scanned. He had a tumour. When it had been removed, his paedophilic tendencies went away. When it started growing back, they returned. When the regrowth was removed, they vanished again. Who then was the child abuser?

His case dramatically illustrates the challenge that modern neuroscience is beginning to pose to the idea of free will. The instinct of the reasonable observer is that organic changes of this sort somehow absolve the sufferer of the responsibility that would accrue to a child abuser whose paedophilia was congenital. But why? The chances are that the latter tendency is just as traceable to brain mechanics as the former; it is merely that no one has yet looked. Scientists have looked at anger and violence, though, and discovered genetic variations, expressed as concentrations of a particular messenger molecule in the brain, that are both congenital and predisposing to a violent temper. Where is free will in this case?

While this example of a tumor in the orbitofrontal cortex is certainly fascinating, I disagree with the philosophical implications that The Economist draws from it. While there certainly are diseases of the brain that are deterministic in nature - no amount of "free will" can cure you of schizophrenia, or Huntington's, or ALS - we should also not assume that every brain disease is equally deterministic. There are two main reasons why I'm not ready to give up on free will.

The first reason is plasticity. One of the great themes of modern neuroscience is the malleability of the mind. While a genetic program specifies the gross anatomy of our brain, the all important details are determined by experience. In fact, the best metaphor for the mind might be our immune system. Just as our antibodies are constantly altered in response to the pathogens we actually encounter (we do not have the B-cells of our parents, or of our identical twin), the brain is constantly adapting to the particular conditions of our own life. This is why blind people can use their visual cortex to read Braille, and why the deaf can process sign language in their auditory cortex. Lose a finger and, thanks to neural plasticity, your other fingers will take over its brain space. In one particularly audacious experiment, the neuroscientist Mriganka Sur literally re-wired the mind of a ferret, so that the information from its retina was plugged into its auditory cortex. To Sur's astonishment, the ferrets could still see. Furthermore, their auditory cortex now resembled the typical ferret visual cortex, complete with spatial maps and neurons tuned to detect slants of light. Michael Merzenich, one of the founders of the plasticity field, called this experiment "The most compelling demonstration you could have that experience shapes the brain."

An important discovery closely related to plasticity has been the discovery of neurogenesis. I've spilled a lot of ink elsewhere on this phenomenon, but it's important to remember that your brain is constantly generating new neurons. The brain, far from being fixed, is actually in a constant state of cellular upheaval.

The second reason I'm not convinced that freedom is nothing but an illusion is the amount of randomness (or stochasticity) inherent in living organisms. Fruit flies, for example, have long hairs on their body that serve as sensory organs. The location and density of those hairs differ between the two sides of the fly, but not in any systematic way. After all, the two sides of the fly are encoded for by the same genes and have developed in the same environment. Instead, the variation in the fly is a consequence of random atomic jostling inside its cells, what biologists call "developmental noise." (This is also why our left and right hands have different fingerprints.)

This same principle is even at work in our brain. Neuroscientist Fred Gage has found that retrotransposons--junk genes which randomly jump around our genome--are present at unusually high numbers in neurons. In fact, these troublemaking scraps of DNA insert themselves into almost 80 percent of our brain cells, arbitrarily altering their genetic program. At first, Gage was befuddled by this data. The brain seemed intentionally destructive, bent on dismantling its own precise instructions. But then Gage had an epiphany. He realized that all these genetic interruptions created a population of perfectly unique minds, since each brain suffered from retrotransposons in its own way. In other words, cellular chaos creates our individuality. Gage's new hypothesis is that all this mental anarchy is adaptive, as it allows our genes to generate minds of almost infinite diversity.

Like the discovery of neurogenesis and neural plasticity, the discovery that biology thrives on disorder is paradigm shifting. The more science knows about life's intricacies, about how DNA actually becomes protein and about how proteins actually become us, the less life resembles a finely honed Swiss clock. Chaos is everywhere. As Karl Popper once said, life is not a clock, it is a cloud. Like a cloud, life is "highly irregular, disorderly, and more or less unpredictable." Clouds, carried and crafted by an infinity of currents, have inscrutable wills; they seethe and tumble in the air, and are a little different with every moment in time. We are the same way. As has happened so many times before in the history of science, the idée fixe of deterministic order proved to be a mirage.

This is why I'm not sorry worried about free will being erased by the facts of biology. Neuroscience hasn't discovered that our mind is nothing but a genetic machine. Far from it. In fact, the most profound discoveries of modern neuroscience have focused on all the ways our mind is not determinstic. Of course, much of this indeterminacy is simply randomness, the stochastic flutter of our cellular machinery. For lack of a better term, I'll call this negative freedom. But a significant part of our freedom is also positive: we are also beginning to understand all the ways the structure of our brain responds to our personal, individual experiences. Free will is here to say. As usual William James said it best, "My first act of free will shall be to believe in free will."

[Thanks for the tip Steve!]

Tags
neuroscience

More like this

In Defense of Buller
David Buller's book, Adapting Minds, is in the news again. I agree with Mixing Memory that many of Buller's specific debunkings - such as his full-throated attack on the cheater module - seem flimsy. (And trust me, I was prepared to believe...In my humble opinion, too much evolutionary psychology…
Teaching the Tongue to See
It's an audacious idea, and I didn't believe it was possible until I saw the video. But it really is possible to teach blind people to see using their tongue. By connecting a camera to an array of electrodes that stimulate the sensitive nerves inside the mouth - a pixel of light is translated into…
Slate
I'm quickly learning that these webmagazines really don't like my book. This review, however, is actually rather thoughtful. Daniel Engber of Slate begins by pointing out that neuroscientists are constantly quoting Proust: My career as a grad student in neuroscience was filled with these obligatory…
Neuroscience and Free Will: The Sequel
My last post on neuroscience and free will generated lots of interesting comments. Please check them out. But I think a few readers misunderstood my ambition. It's easiest to begin by saying what I wasn't trying to do: I wasn't trying to construct a philosophically sound defense of free will (I'm…

Free will? Oh boy, here we go again.

1) First, before attempting to prove or disprove free will, you should define it. Even perfeshunal philosophers frequently try to save free will by redefining it, and that just doesn't accomplish anything.

2) Why do you think plasticity is going to save free will? Is neurogenesis somehow exempt from natural laws? Or does your conception of "determinism" only cover genetic programming and not the laws of nature? I don't see a point in getting too deeply into this one until you have provided your definition of free will.

3) Randomness? I think you're on the wrong track there. Most people's conception of free will is not randomness.

Now a quote from "Free" Will Provine:

Compatibilist-free will yields so little freedom to crow about in the first place, but the philosophers up on modern science want free will so badly that writing a whole book (or two of them) is the norm.

By Mustafa Mond, FCD (not verified) on 20 Dec 2006 #permalink

As usual William James said it best, "My first act of free will shall be to believe in free will."

Of course James would say that, he was pre-determined to.

By Mustafa Mond, FCD (not verified) on 20 Dec 2006 #permalink

I dread philosophical discussions of free will just as much as the next person. Of course, there are many different defintions of free will, and parsing their details is way beyond my limited qualifications. I was simply trying to demonstrate why neuroscience isn't becoming a deterministic science, one that is bound to erase our "free will." And I agree that most people's conception of free will isn't randomness. Nevertheless, I believe that the stochastic flux at the center of life provide us with the "elbow room" that makes free will possible.

As for myself, I will wait for someone to give a coherent definition of free will and provide evidence that it exists, before I spend time wondering what makes it possible.

By Mustafa Mond, FCD (not verified) on 20 Dec 2006 #permalink

I think you need to be careful about using the term 'indeterminate'; it can mean a slew of things, all the way from the indeterminancy of quantum measurements, all the way to a mere 'I can't predict the result, knowing what I know'. And in the end, nothing is really indeterminate; the equation of motion of the universe is deterministic, as far as we know.

The 'stochastic randomness' of molecules diffusing towards receptors is closer to the ''can't predict" definition. It's entirely governed by deterministic physical laws; we're just not in a position to measure the initial conditions or calculate the evolution of the system from those conditions.

We are machines which are designed to see ourselves as free actors. It makes no sense to worry about whether in fact we are deterministic machines at the moelcular level - of course we are - any more than it makes sense to analyse a computer's operating system in terms of 1s and 0s.

The brain is plastic AND remarkably stable. Two-photon imagng of live animals has shown that dendritic spines in the adult mouse hardly change.

"I view the standard philosophical terminology as worse than useless--a major obstacle to progress since it consists of so many errors" - Daniel Dennett

Free will requires mind-body dualism to be a meaningful concept. Without a non-physical mind to talk about, free will degenerates into either the "can't practically predict" definition, in which case it is trite, or the "not bound by physical laws" definition, in which case it is absurd.

Hi,

I think that there is no set of descriptive scientific theories that can erase the notion of free will as subjective concept. When I do something, I am supposing that what I do is because of my decisions, thoughts, will, etc.

You´re invited to my philosophy blog!

Plasticity doesn't save free will. "Determined by experience" means just that _determined_. Adding in more levels doesn't result in free will but just a more complex deterministic process.

And the randomness you talk about is just determinism with an occasional dice thrown in.

The only solution is to adopt an instrumentalist stance towards free will.

In sentencing the man with the tumor, we have no more choice in sentencing him that he had in committing those acts.

on a side note: There is no moral dilemma if we get away from our view of prison as punishment. Prison should be about rehabilitation. If the man, with his tumor removed, is no longer a danger to society then he should be released. If he is still a danger to society then he shouldn't be released.

Largely supporting Gerard Harbison' viewpoint, I would warn against confusion of arbitrary "randomness", "stochasticity" (these terms define probabilistic phenomena) with the mathematical definition of "chaotic" and "fractal patterns" (these are totally deterministic).

Thus, Fred Gage is correct in the above citation, but he is, in my opinion, grossly misrepresented:

---
"This same principle is even at work in our brain. Neuroscientist Fred Gage has found that retrotransposons--junk genes which randomly jump around our genome--are present at unusually high numbers in neurons. In fact, these troublemaking scraps of DNA insert themselves into almost 80 percent of our brain cells, arbitrarily altering their genetic program. At first, Gage was befuddled by this data. The brain seemed intentionally destructive, bent on dismantling its own precise instructions. But then Gage had an epiphany. He realized that all these genetic interruptions created a population of perfectly unique minds, since each brain suffered from retrotransposons in its own way. In other words, cellular chaos creates our individuality. Gage's new hypothesis is that all this mental anarchy is adaptive, as it allows our genes to generate minds of almost infinite diversity"
---

Knowing Fred Gage, I would not like to think he used the word "arbitrarily", or if he did, used it more in the sense that there is an "arbiter" (deterministic laws governing), rather than "arbitrarily" used in the sense of "randomly".

In view of the explosion in our knowledge (if not yet in our understanding) of short repetitive elements of DNA and RNA, (most of them emanating from Junk DNA) and the current findings (see at http://www.junkdna.com/new_citations.html) that the (human) DNA leaves about 1/8 for DIVERSITY, it may just be that the fractal (and, mathematically, chaotic) patterns governing our neural networks make our individual thinking different from one-another.

pellionisz_at_junkdna.com

I dread philosophical discussions of free will just as much as the next person. Of course, there are many different defintions of free will, and parsing their details is way beyond my limited qualifications. I was simply trying to demonstrate why neuroscience isn't becoming a deterministic science, one that is bound to erase our "free will." And I agree that most people's conception of free will isn't randomness. Nevertheless, I believe that the stochastic flux at the center of life provide us with the "elbow room" that makes free will possible.

Here it is, in a nutshell. This is why atheists and materialists are called 'not nice people'. You fail to back up your claims, and yet you refuse to retract them. If I call you on this bit of nonrationality, to allow you to have your warm-and-fuzzy emotionally driven comfort blanket, you will consider me to be mean. Go ahead then, cling to your blankie. Just don't confuse it with rational argument.

By Mustafa Mond, FCD (not verified) on 21 Dec 2006 #permalink

That was a very good, thought provoking post. I did read the original article in Economist and I think that neuroscience is blurring the very definition of free will. In fact so much so that free will suddenly is starting to become vapor-like to me and seems to not exist (or exist in a much narrower space). Risking being a dunce on the internet, I would stake a claim to say that the very fact that experience driven genetic modification of synapses means that we DO NOT have free will. In fact the very argument that you had put out in favor of free will (neurogenesis and synaptic plasticity) is also paradoxically against it. In many cases a human being seems to be driven to certain actions because of the very fact that experience driven genetic modifications lead to plasticity of neural substrates and those original environmental experiences are codified and wired into an individuals brain helped by a process of neurogenesis. Propagating these two arguments for free will does not seem to cut this argument - at least in my own humble way...

Swami Vivekanandas definition of free will:
the very words free will are a contradiction, because will is what we know, and everything that we know is within our universe, and everything within our universe is molded by conditions of time, space and causality. ... To acquire freedom we have to get beyond the limitations of this universe; it cannot be found here.

That was a very good, thought provoking post. I did read the original article in Economist and I think that neuroscience is blurring the very definition of free will. In fact so much so that free will suddenly is starting to become vapor-like to me and seems to not exist (or exist in a much narrower space). Risking being a dunce on the internet, I would stake a claim to say that the very fact that experience driven genetic modification of synapses means that we DO NOT have free will. In fact the very argument that you had put out in favor of free will (neurogenesis and synaptic plasticity) is also paradoxically against it. In many cases a human being seems to be driven to certain actions because of the very fact that experience driven genetic modifications lead to plasticity of neural substrates and those original environmental experiences are codified and wired into an individuals brain helped by a process of neurogenesis. Propagating these two arguments for free will does not seem to cut this argument - at least in my own humble way...

Swami Vivekanandas definition of free will:
the very words free will are a contradiction, because will is what we know, and everything that we know is within our universe, and everything within our universe is molded by conditions of time, space and causality. ... To acquire freedom we have to get beyond the limitations of this universe; it cannot be found here.

To really have a "free will" we would need to get rid of all the senses, needs and motivations, since all these external and internal influences affect our executive output. What would left to constitute the free will is hard for me to imagine.

We don't know whether stochaistic or chaotic event series are deterministic or indeterministic. There are fully developed mathematical theories of chaos that are indeterministic and those that are deterministic. So Dr. Pellionisz's assertion that such chaotic or stochaistic patterns are deterministic is unwarranted.

Lincoln's assertion that all human experience is determined by prior experience is also unwarranted. The fact that past human experience may affect or influence our behavior doesn't warrant the inference that all human behavior is determined by past experience. There is a good deal of novelty and creativity in human behavior and interaction. The notion assumed by Lincoln and ivan here, input-output, just isn't truly descriptive of human behaviors requiring imagination, foresight, creativity, rationality and moral judgment -- not to mention the phenomenal nature of consciousness itself (which is no mere output of an input or computers would already be conscious).

However, it appears that the chaotic neral patterns of the cortex are capable of self-organizing into ordered patterns and that ordered brain activity arises from such chaos. A lot more work needs to be done before we can get dogmatic about free will. It may well be that the reafferant feed-back systems give rise to an emergent experience of consciousness of the self that then can downwardly cause brain activity. Bio-feedback rests on such principals so that we are not merely the result of brain or neural events, but the brain's very behavior is the result of "conscious choices" that then effect the brain's neural behavior.

I don't know enough about the stochaistic or chaotic patterns of DNA formation to have an opinion about what role it may or may not play in formation of the brain's "make-up".

However, I agree with Dr. Andras J. Pellionisz (if I have properly understood him) to the extent he warns against equating random and chaotic events with free will. Free actions for which we could be held accountable as an agent are not merely random or chaotic. The very notion of free will requires something like an emergent self (arising from up-ward causation of neural events but which can transcend mere events as such) that can exercise downward causation in making choices, acting and so forth. However, while there is a great deal of data that suggests that there is indeed the ability to make such choices and that we are not merely our brains because we also act upon the brain as it responds to decisions we make, we just don't know enough yet to begin making final conclusions. The issue remains philosophical despite some advances in neuroscience.

Can free will and naturalism coexist? Are you a philosophical naturalist?

mbjdcq dakfqhc uabfxwh
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib102 Adult Dating,Adult Dating Site,Adult Dating Free,Adult Dating Service,Adult Dating Online,Adult Dating Services,Adult Dating Sex,Adult Sex Dating,Dating Adult,Free Adult Dating,Adult Dating Sites,Online Adult Dating,Adult Dating Personals,Free Adult Dating Sites,Adult Xxx Dating,Craig Adult Dating,Adult Online Dating,Adult Dating Personal,Adult Dating Chat,Adult Single Dating,Review Adult Dating,Adult Dating Web Site,Adult Dating Services Online,Ads Adult Dating,Free Adult Dating Site,Free Adult Dating Service,Asian Adult Dating,Adult Dating Uk,Adult Personals Dating,Adult Dating Agency

mbjdcq dakfqhc uabfxwh
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib102 Adult Dating,Adult Dating Site,Adult Dating Free,Adult Dating Service,Adult Dating Online,Adult Dating Services,Adult Dating Sex,Adult Sex Dating,Dating Adult,Free Adult Dating,Adult Dating Sites,Online Adult Dating,Adult Dating Personals,Free Adult Dating Sites,Adult Xxx Dating,Craig Adult Dating,Adult Online Dating,Adult Dating Personal,Adult Dating Chat,Adult Single Dating,Review Adult Dating,Adult Dating Web Site,Adult Dating Services Online,Ads Adult Dating,Free Adult Dating Site,Free Adult Dating Service,Asian Adult Dating,Adult Dating Uk,Adult Personals Dating,Adult Dating Agency

iwzy tzne
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib103 Free Dating,Free Online Dating,Free Dating Sites,Free Dating Service,Free Dating Online,Adult Dating Free,Free Dating Site,Free Dating Services,Free Transgender Dating Sites,Free Adult Dating,Free Online Dating Sites,Free Dating Websites,Free Online Dating Service,Free Sex Dating,Free Dating Online Service,Free Online Dating Services,Dating Free Online,Free Christian Dating,Free Internet Dating,Dating Free,Totally Free Dating Sites,100 Free Dating,Totally Free Dating,Free Single Dating,Free Adult Dating Sites,Free Dating Personals,Free Gay Dating,Free Phone Dating,Free On Line Dating,Completely Free Dating,Free Online Dating Personals,Free Online Dating Site

zjoqwbp ukcx xtnv jxtr
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib104 Dating Sites,Free Dating Sites,Free Transgender Dating Sites,Free Online Dating Sites,Adult Dating Sites,Sites Dating,Online Dating Sites,Dating Site,Adult Dating Site,Free Dating Site,Online Dating Site,Site Dating,Dating Web Site,Sex Dating Sites,Christian Dating Sites,Totally Free Dating Sites,Teen Dating Sites,Dating Web Sites,Interracial Dating Sites,Asian Dating Sites,Free Adult Dating Sites,Internet Dating Sites,Gay Dating Sites,Black Dating Sites,Lesbian Dating Sites,Bbw Dating Sites,Latin Women Dating Sites,100 Free Dating Sites,Herpes Dating Sites,Dating Sites In New Zealand ,Free Christian Dating Sites,Singles Dating Sites

pgtk xrwhfn csinqj
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib105 Dating Services,Free Dating Services,Adult Dating Services,Online Dating Services,Services Dating,Free Online Dating Services,Internet Dating Services,Christian Dating Services,Dating Service,Free Dating Service,Online Dating Service,Adult Dating Service,Christian Dating Service,Dating Internet Service,Internet Dating Service,Service Dating,Free Online Dating Service,Free Dating Online Service,Senior Dating Service,Dating Service Dating Site,Gay Dating Services,Lesbian Dating Services,Dating Services Online,International Dating Services,Adult Dating Services Online,Online Jewish Dating Services,Black Dating Services,Local Free Online Dating Services,On Line Dating Services,Singles Dating Services

scjq
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib107 Sex Dating,Dating Sex,Hotties Dating Sex,Adult Dating Sex,Adult Sex Dating,Free Sex Dating,Sex Dating Sites,Dating For Sex,Online Sex Dating,Sex Dating Site,Totally Free Sex Dating,Free Sex Dating Sites,Dating Sex Sites,Sex Dating Delaware,Sex Dating Online,Gratis Sex Dating,Stripper Sex Dating Site,Sex And Dating,Free Older Women Sex Dating,Sex Dating Services,Free Adult Sex Dating,Mature Sex Dating,Sex Dublin Sex In Dublin Dating Ireland,Online Dating Sex,Adult Personals Sex Dating,Sex Or Relationship Or Dating Or Romance,Free Dating Sex,Dating And Sex,Dating Sex Personals,Sex And Dating Forum

scjq
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib107 Sex Dating,Dating Sex,Hotties Dating Sex,Adult Dating Sex,Adult Sex Dating,Free Sex Dating,Sex Dating Sites,Dating For Sex,Online Sex Dating,Sex Dating Site,Totally Free Sex Dating,Free Sex Dating Sites,Dating Sex Sites,Sex Dating Delaware,Sex Dating Online,Gratis Sex Dating,Stripper Sex Dating Site,Sex And Dating,Free Older Women Sex Dating,Sex Dating Services,Free Adult Sex Dating,Mature Sex Dating,Sex Dublin Sex In Dublin Dating Ireland,Online Dating Sex,Adult Personals Sex Dating,Sex Or Relationship Or Dating Or Romance,Free Dating Sex,Dating And Sex,Dating Sex Personals,Sex And Dating Forum

apdszt xmftl
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib108 Black Dating,Black Dating Online,Black And White Dating,Black Dating Sites,Black Dating Site,Black Women Dating White Men,Black Dating Services,Free Black Dating,Black Christian Dating,Black Online Dating,Black Cock Dating,White Men Dating Black Women,Black Online Dating Sites,Black Man Dating White Woman,Black Lesbian Dating,Black Women Dating,Black Dating Service,Black Dating Websites,Interracial Dating Black Women,Dating Black Women,Dating Black Men,Free Black Dating Sites,White Women Black Men Dating,Black Gay Dating,Dating Black,Black Sexy Babes Dating Free Site,Black White Dating,Black Senior Dating Sites,Black Men Dating Black Women,Black Men Dating

skovm
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib109 Interracial Dating,Interracial Dating Sites,Online Interracial Dating Service,Interracial Dating Central,Interracial Dating Site,Interracial Dating Service,Interracial Dating Online,Interracial Dating Websites,Interracial Online Dating,Free Interracial Dating,Interracial Dating Personals,Interracial Dating Services,Interracial Gay Dating,Bob Jones University Interracial Dating,Interracial Dating Black Women,Gay Interracial Dating,Free Interracial Dating Sites,Interracial Dating Plentyoffish,Interracial Dating In The Sixties,Interracial Dating Articles,Interracial Sex Dating,Interracial Dating Marriage,Christian Interracial Dating,Interracial Dating In Washington Dc,Interracial Dating Among Celebrities,Teen Interracial Dating,Interracial Dating Website,Dating Interracial

nrpsfc
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib110 Internet Dating,Dating Internet Service,Internet Dating Service,Internet Dating Services,Free Internet Dating,Internet Dating Sites,About Internet Dating,Dating Internet,Internet Dating Site,Internet Dating Scams,Free Internet Dating Sites,Free Internet Dating Services,Internet Dating Servics,Internet Dating Sacramento California,Dating On The Internet,Free Internet Dating Service,Internet Speed Dating,Internet Dating Site Reviews,Best Internet Dating Site,Free Internet Dating Websites,Dating Internet Sites,Internet Dating Agency,Internet Dating Free,Internet Dating Advice,Dating Internet Services,Christian Internet Dating,Dangers Of Internet Dating,Free Internet Dating Uk,Internet Dating Statistics,Free Internet Dating Site

blyjd
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib111 Christian Dating,Christian Dating Service,Dating Christian,Christian Dating Services,Free Christian Dating,Christian Dating Sites,Christian Singles Dating,Christian Online Dating,Online Christian Dating Service,Free Online Christian Dating,Free Christian Dating Sites,Christian Dating Site,Black Christian Dating,Christian Dating Advice,Free Christian Dating Service,Christian Dating And Personals Service,Christian Dating Websites,Christian Dating Kw,Christian Single Dating,Christian Speed Dating,Free Christian Dating Services,Christian Dating Online,Christian Online Dating Service,Christian Dating Service Online,Online Christian Dating,Christian Dating Free,Free Christian Dating Services Colorado Springs,Nude Christian Dating,Christian Dating Services In Colorado

ovmrix bfdl cebpkhl
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib112 Lesbian Dating,Lesbian Online Dating,Lesbian Dating Services,Lesbian Dating Sites,Free Lesbian Dating,Lesbian Dating Service,Free Lesbian Dating Sites,Lesbian Dating Site,Black Lesbian Dating,Lesbian Online Dating Services,Gay Lesbian Dating,Dating Lesbian,Lesbian Dating Online,Online Lesbian Dating,Lesbian Dating Uk,Lesbian Dating Websites,Lesbian Dating Agencies,Lesbian Dating Advice,Lesbian Dating Tips,Lesbian Speed Dating Liverpool,Free Lesbian Dating Site,Gay And Lesbian Dating,Free Lesbian Dating Service,Lesbian Speed Dating,Girls Kissing Lesbian Teens Dating Sex,Lesbian Dating Pics,Free Lesbian Dating Services,Lesbian Flash Dating Games

qxaigp bgyasp ldcnbyw cljh
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib113 Gay Dating,Gay Dating Services,Free Gay Dating,Gay Dating Sites,Gay Dating Service,Gay Online Dating,Dating Gay,Gay Dating Site,Free Gay Dating Sites,Gay Dating Agency,Gay Dating Websites,Gay Teen Dating,Interracial Gay Dating,Gay Interracial Dating,Gay Men Dating,Gay Lesbian Dating,Gay Asian Dating,Gay Christian Dating,Gay Male Dating,Gay Anal Dating Service,Black Gay Dating,Free Gay Dating Service,Gay Dating Tips,Gay Dating Bradford,Gay Sex Dating,Gay Online Dating Service,Free Gay Dating Services,Anderson Cooper Gay And Dating,Gay Speed Dating

vhgxb ymrug hlqsjc
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib114 Dating Direct,Direct Dating,Dating Direct Datingdirect,Dating Direct Com,Dating Direct Uk,Dating Direct Com,Dating Direct My Account,Direct Dating Uk,Somerset County Direct Paper Dating,Uniform Direct Dating,Newcastle Dating Direct,Direct Dating Com,Dates From Hell Dating Direct,Direct Internet Dating,Search Dating Direct,Dating Direct Number,What Dating Direct,How Do I Cancel Dating Direct,Find Out When Dating Direct Is Working,Dating Direct Co Uk,Dating En Direct,Site Www Datingdirect Com Dating Direct,Dating Dating Direct Sims,Dating Direct Link Personals Shagdr Com,Dating Direct Hull Kingston Upon,Tiscali Dating Direct,Direct Adult Dating

frqzum sykgvnp
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib115 Speed Dating,Dating Speed,Speed Dating Cnn,Speed Dating Pocker,New York Speed Dating,Pocket Change Speed Dating,Christian Speed Dating,Speed Dating Poker,Asian Speed Dating,Speed Dating Questions,Houston Speed Dating,San Francisco Speed Dating,Speed Dating New York,Minneapolis Speed Dating,New York City Speed Dating,Seattle Speed Dating,Charlotte Speed Dating,Speed Dating Philadelphia,Ovraw Speed Dating,Los Angeles Speed Dating,Indiana Speed Dating,Long Island Speed Dating,Tulsa Speed Dating,Speed Dating Milwaukee,Speed Dating And New York,Speed Dating Orange County,Speed Dating Montreal,Speed Dating Seattle,San Diego Speed Dating,Speed Dating Nyc

jektv
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib116 Single Dating,Dating Single,Single Parent Dating,Free Single Dating,Adult Single Dating,Single Dating At The Movies,Single Net Dating,Online Single Dating Site,Single Parents Dating,Singles Dating,Dating Singles,Christian Singles Dating,Dating Service Singles,Dating Online Singles,Singles Dating Sites,Christian Single Dating,Single Online Dating,Single Parents Online Dating Web Site,Free Single Dating Site,Single Dating Service,Single Parents Dating Service,Single Dating Site,Single Dating Edmonton,Dating Single Parent,Single Edmonton Dating,Dating For Single Parents,Single Dating Sites,Free Single Dating Sites

zwondk bpcnm
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib117 Senior Dating,Senior Dating Service,Senior Dating Sites,Free Senior Dating,Senior Dating Services,Free Senior Dating Sites,Black Senior Dating Sites,Senior Sex Dating,Dating Senior,Senior Singles Dating,Senior Dating Websites,Black Senior Dating Site,Senior Online Dating,Senior Citizen Dating,Senior Christian Dating,Hot Sexy Senior Dating,Senior Citizens Dating,Tulsa Senior Dating,Christian Senior Singles Dating,Dating Married Senior Women,Dating Senior Sex,Black Senior Dating,Nevada Senior Dating Service,High School Senior Girls Dating Freshmen Guys,Sexy Senior Dating,Free Senior Dating Service In Phoenix,Senior Speed Dating

camd vmjswab bvxt dfoy
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib118 Dating Tips,Online Dating Tips,Dating Tips For Teens,Dating Tips For Women,Teen Dating Tips,Teenage Dating Tips,Dating Tips For Men,Tips On Dating,Free Dating Tips,Tips For Dating,Teenage Dating Tips For Girls,Dating Tips For Guys,Speed Dating Tips,Tons Of Photos And Helpful Dating Tips,Gay Dating Tips,Tips For Dating Parents,Christian Dating Tips,Dating Relationship Tips Dealing With Rejection,Dating Tips For Girls,Lesbian Dating Tips,Dating Tips And Hints,High School Dating Tips,Dating Tips For Boys,Headline Username Tips Online Dating,Tips Dating Leo Taurus,Tips Dating,Free Dating Tips For Men,Good Dating Tips

camd vmjswab bvxt dfoy
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib118 Dating Tips,Online Dating Tips,Dating Tips For Teens,Dating Tips For Women,Teen Dating Tips,Teenage Dating Tips,Dating Tips For Men,Tips On Dating,Free Dating Tips,Tips For Dating,Teenage Dating Tips For Girls,Dating Tips For Guys,Speed Dating Tips,Tons Of Photos And Helpful Dating Tips,Gay Dating Tips,Tips For Dating Parents,Christian Dating Tips,Dating Relationship Tips Dealing With Rejection,Dating Tips For Girls,Lesbian Dating Tips,Dating Tips And Hints,High School Dating Tips,Dating Tips For Boys,Headline Username Tips Online Dating,Tips Dating Leo Taurus,Tips Dating,Free Dating Tips For Men,Good Dating Tips

bwyqg uisgpf
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib119 Dating Websites,Free Dating Websites,Online Dating Websites,Dating Website,Free Dating Website,Online Dating Website,Christian Dating Website,Christian Dating Websites,Interracial Dating Websites,Teen Dating Websites,Gay Dating Websites,Black Dating Websites,Adult Dating Websites,Free Online Dating Websites,Free Christian Dating Websites,Sexual Dating Websites,Catholic Dating Websites,Lesbian Dating Websites,Free Adult Dating Websites,Bbw Dating Websites,Totally Free Dating Websites,Free Internet Dating Websites,100 Free Dating Websites,Best Dating Websites,Singles Dating Websites,African American Dating Websites,Unique Dating Websites,Marijuana Dating Websites

fkgqvb iokz
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib120 Dating Advice,Teen Dating Advice,Online Dating Advice,Christian Dating Advice,Dating Advice For Women,Free Dating Advice,Dating Advice For Men,Dating Advice For Teens,Couples Dating Advice Cell Phones Relationships,Dating Relationship Advice,Advice On Dating,Love And Dating Advice,Lesbian Dating Advice,Teenage Dating Advice,Internet Dating Advice,Advice Dating,Love Dating Advice,Dating Advice For Man,Commitment Issues Dating Relationship Advice,Advice On Dating A Married Man,Dating Women With Children Advice,Dating Advice More Than Friends,Christian Advice On Dating,Gay Dating Advice,Advice On Dating Older Men,Dating Advice For Guys,Dating Advice Forum

cuztx kbrg ojmcp
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib121 Asian Dating,Asian Dating Sites,Asian Adult Dating,Asian Dating Service,Asian Dating Site,Dating Asian Women,Asian Speed Dating,Free Asian Dating,Dating Asian,Asian Women Dating,Gay Asian Dating,Asian Online Dating,Asian American Dating,Asian Dating Services,Asian Dating Free,Dating Asian Men,Asian Dating Online,Dating Asian Sexygirls,Black Women Dating Asian Men,Asian Sex Dating,Free Asian Dating Sites,Black And Asian Dating,Asian Dating Sex,Dating Asian Woman,Asian Dating Free Site,Asian Men Dating Black Women,Dating Asian Girls,Online Dating Asian

cuztx kbrg ojmcp
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib121 Asian Dating,Asian Dating Sites,Asian Adult Dating,Asian Dating Service,Asian Dating Site,Dating Asian Women,Asian Speed Dating,Free Asian Dating,Dating Asian,Asian Women Dating,Gay Asian Dating,Asian Online Dating,Asian American Dating,Asian Dating Services,Asian Dating Free,Dating Asian Men,Asian Dating Online,Dating Asian Sexygirls,Black Women Dating Asian Men,Asian Sex Dating,Free Asian Dating Sites,Black And Asian Dating,Asian Dating Sex,Dating Asian Woman,Asian Dating Free Site,Asian Men Dating Black Women,Dating Asian Girls,Online Dating Asian

oluwmr
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib122 Jewish Dating,Online Jewish Dating Services,Jewish Dating Service,Jewish Dating Services,Jewish Singles Dating,Jewish Dating Sites,Jewish Dating Site,Jewish Online Dating,Jewish Speed Dating,Free Jewish Dating,Dating Jewish,Jewish Singles Dating Service,Russian Jewish Dating,Dating Jewish Site,Jewish Dating Agencies,Jewish Online Dating Services,Orthodox Jewish Dating,Jewish Dating Websites,Single Jewish Dating,Jewish Dating Network,Gay Jewish Dating,Old Fashioned Jewish Dating,Jewish Singles Jewish Dating,Is It Different Dating Religious Jewish Girl,Jewish Dating Toronto,Jewish Orthodox Dating,Jewish Dating Philadelphia,Free Jewish Dating Services

wzvar
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib123 Bbw Dating,Bbw Dating Sites,Free Bbw Online Dating,Bbw Online Dating,Free Bbw Dating,Dating Bbw,Bbw Dating Site,Free Bbw Dating Sites,Bbw Dating Service,Bbw Dating Websites,Bbw Dating Services,Bbw Sex Dating,Bbw Adult Dating,Free Bbw Dating Site,Bbw Dating New Jersey,Blue Eye Bbw Dating,Bbw Internet Dating,Bbw Free Dating,Adult Bbw Dating,Bbw And Dating,Bbw Dating Online,Free Bbw Dating Services,Dating Sites For Bbw,Black Bbw Dating,Bbw Interracial Dating,Bbw Singles Dating,Bbw Dating Free,Bbw Dating Website

wzvar
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib123 Bbw Dating,Bbw Dating Sites,Free Bbw Online Dating,Bbw Online Dating,Free Bbw Dating,Dating Bbw,Bbw Dating Site,Free Bbw Dating Sites,Bbw Dating Service,Bbw Dating Websites,Bbw Dating Services,Bbw Sex Dating,Bbw Adult Dating,Free Bbw Dating Site,Bbw Dating New Jersey,Blue Eye Bbw Dating,Bbw Internet Dating,Bbw Free Dating,Adult Bbw Dating,Bbw And Dating,Bbw Dating Online,Free Bbw Dating Services,Dating Sites For Bbw,Black Bbw Dating,Bbw Interracial Dating,Bbw Singles Dating,Bbw Dating Free,Bbw Dating Website

ecjq wshyu
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib124 On Line Dating,Dating On Line,Free On Line Dating,On Line Dating Services,Free In Line Dating Services,Dating Line,Free On Line Dating Services,How To Open A Dating Business On Line,Free Dating On Line,Babyboomers Dating Line,Local Dating Service Chat Line,On Line Dating Service,On Line Dating Sites,Dating Phone Line,Line Dating,Free On Line Dating Sites,Dating Chat Line,Free On Line Dating Service,Dallas Dating Chat Line,Christian On Line Dating,Women On Line Dating,Phone Dating Line,Canadian Dating Line,On Line Dating For Free,On Line Dating Site,One Line Dating,Adult Dating On Line

pcuedn fdtcxmb
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib125 Married Dating,Dating Married Women,Dating A Married Man,Dating Married Men,Dating Married,Married Dating Sites,Married And Dating,Married Women Dating,Dating Married Woman,Free Married Dating,Married Adult Dating,Married Woman Dating,Married But Dating,Dating Married Man,Married Dating Service,Online Dating Married,Married Dating Club,Adult Married Dating Services,Dating For Married People,Free Married Dating Site,Married Dating Site,Dating A Married Woman,Free Married Dating Sites,Married Dating Sex,Married Older Women Dating Younger Men,Married People Dating,Dating And Married

pcuedn fdtcxmb
http://protectthearctic.org/lib/lib125 Married Dating,Dating Married Women,Dating A Married Man,Dating Married Men,Dating Married,Married Dating Sites,Married And Dating,Married Women Dating,Dating Married Woman,Free Married Dating,Married Adult Dating,Married Woman Dating,Married But Dating,Dating Married Man,Married Dating Service,Online Dating Married,Married Dating Club,Adult Married Dating Services,Dating For Married People,Free Married Dating Site,Married Dating Site,Dating A Married Woman,Free Married Dating Sites,Married Dating Sex,Married Older Women Dating Younger Men,Married People Dating,Dating And Married

Let me just say: wow, what a relief it is to find someone who actually know what they are talking about on the internet! More people need to read this.

Let me just say: wow, what a relief it is to find someone who actually know what they are talking about on the internet! More people need to read this.