Impressionism and Blindness

It's long been noted that the impressionists steadily grew more abstract as the 19th century came to a close. One only has to compare an early Monet from the 1870's to a late Monet landscape to understand the importance of this transition. The pretty pastels and dappling light gave way to thick impasto paints and blank spots on the canvas. In other words, the impressionists had become post-impressionists.

This transition is usually explained in terms of culture: the impressionists were simply reacting to the increasing acceptance of painterly abstraction. Modernism was beginning, verisimilitude was a thing of the past. But art historians are also beginning to explore a related hypothesis: perhaps the late works of the impressionists were partly due to eye troubles.

The impressionists, after all, were an ophthalmologists nightmare. Monet became blind due to cataracts (but didn't stop painting the bridges of Giverny). Vincent Van Gogh, drinker of kerosene, turpentine, and absinthe, probably thought the coronas he painted around stars and streetlamps were real. Edgar Degas became severely myopic, which led him to do more and more sculpture ("I must learn a blind man's trade now," Degas said.) Auguste Renoir, poisoned by his pastel paints, became a rheumatic cripple.

Dr. Michael F. Marmor, a professor of ophthalmology at Stanford, used computer simulations to try to understand what, exactly, happened to the vision of these aged impressionists.

"Here we can see ourselves what they were seeing through their eyes," Dr. Marmor said. "Critics have known that these men had failing vision, but I don't think they could appreciate what it meant to these artists. It gives both new respect for what they could do with limited vision, but also gives us reason to re-examine perhaps what these paintings mean in the evolution of these artists' style and work."


Works by Edgar Degas in 1886, left, and 1905, center. Right, an image altered to show what Degas would have seen working on the 1905 piece.


More like this

As I note in my book, the most famous impressionists all suffered from serious medical problems: Monet became blind (but didn't stop painting the bridges of Giverny). Vincent Van Gogh, drinker of kerosene, turpentine, and absinthe, probably thought the coronas he painted around stars and…
An article in the NY Times discusses the work of Michael Marmor, a professor of ophthalmology at Stanford School of Medicine who has created a computer simulation of how eye diseases such as macular degeneration and cataracts have affected the painting styles of a number of impressionist artists.…
Many famous artists and musicians have had the perception of their own art altered by abnormal physical or mental changes. Critics and historians have often credited these changes as major sources of creativity. Insanity and Drugs seem to usually be the most cited and obvious candidates but very…
Geese at Standley Lake (soft pastel and charchol on canvas) by Karmen Lee Franklin, 2007 It seems that in life, nothing ever turns out as expected. Over the past week, which was, of course, National Wildlife Week, I participated in the Blogger Bioblitz. The experience was loads of fun, quite…

The same could be said about one of the painters of the romantic period who was an inspiration to the impressionists J.M.W. Tuener.

By natural cynic (not verified) on 17 Apr 2007 #permalink

so how do they explain the cubists? astigmatism?