Space Anomalies

How would science ever progress without anomalies? Theories are useful things, but they are most useful when they're wrong, when their Newtonian predictions are off, as in the case of the Pioneer space probes, by a hundred-millionths of an inch per second for every second of spaceflight. Robert Lee Hotz has the fascinating story:

Beyond the edge of the solar system, something has gradually dragged two of America's oldest space probes -- Pioneer 10 and Pioneer 11 -- a quarter-million miles off course. Astrophysicists have struggled 15 years in vain to identify the infinitesimal force at play. The Pioneer anomaly, as it is called, throws a monkey wrench into celestial mechanics.

Slava Turyshev may have found the answer in NASA's trash. Reconstructing decades of discarded spacecraft data, the Russian-born astrophysicist and the private space enthusiasts helping him say they believe they are on the verge of solving a mystery of time and gravity that has perplexed a generation of physicists and might have confounded Newton and Einstein.

Bonus fact: Did you know that the moon's actual orbit is off its calculated course by about six millimeters a year?

This reminds me of one of my favorite philosophy of science papers: "Do the Laws of Physics State the Facts," by Nancy Cartwright. Her answer, surprisingly, is no:"Not only do the laws of physics have exceptions; unlike biological laws, they are not even true for the most part, or approximately true."

Via Kottke

More like this

There are so many lessons in this story it is hard to know where to start. First, don't throw away data. Second, scientists do question their own dogma and in fact get rather excited about it. Third, Click and Clack (Car Talk) glossed their answer to a question the other day (sort of) ... it…
Before getting into this, I just want to give you the best quote about physics from a physicist I've seen in a long time. In describing the phenomenon we are discussing here, JPL scientist Slava Turyshev says, "The effect is something like when you're driving a car and the photons from your…
Today is the International Day for World Biodiversity, a favorite holiday of the Bush White House. Events 1906 - Wright brothers are granted patent number 821,393 for their "Flying-Machine". 1969 - Apollo 10's lunar module flies within 8.4 nautical miles (16 km) of the moon's surface. Births 1911…
Events 1967 - Vladimir Komarov dies in Soyuz 1 becoming the first human to die during a space mission. 1990 - STS-31: The Hubble Space Telescope is launched by the Space Shuttle Discovery. Births 1899 - Oscar Zariski, Russian-born mathematician 1947 - Roger D. Kornberg, American chemist Deaths…

So 30% is attributable to radiant heat. Presumably anisotropic or it would not have an effect on the velocity.

What about the energy radiated directionally from the Earth-pointing antenna? We are told the magnitude but not the direction of the anomaly.

Very cool, about rescuing all the old data.

By Gray Gaffer (not verified) on 16 May 2008 #permalink

Slava Turyshev may have found the answer in NASA's trash. Reconstructing decades of discarded spacecraft data, the Russian-born astrophysicist and the private space enthusiasts helping him say they believe they are on the verge of solving a mystery of time and gravity that has perplexed a generation of physicists and might have confounded Newton and Einstein.