Religious Ritual

Allegra Goodman is a marvelous writer. Intuition, her last novel, was an uncannily accurate depiction of the slog of a science lab. It captured the epic tedium of empiricism, the way experiments are ambiguous even when they work. (And they so rarely work!) I bring her up now because she just wrote a gorgeous few paragraphs on religion, faith and doubt. The piece doesn't neatly slot into the religious wars of scienceblogs - Goodman isn't devout about anything - but it manages to express an idea that I often struggle to put in words. She begins by talking about the boredom of a child when confronted with religious ritual, the interminable boredom that is shul. But then, at a certain point, she begins to appreciate the strange songs and ceremonies:

And yet, inexorably, some of my own religion rubbed off on me. Might that be the way belief works for some people? Not a sudden epiphany but a long, slow accumulation of Sabbaths. No road-to-Damascus conversion but a kind of coin rubbing, in which ritual and repetition begin to reveal the credo underneath. As I grew older, I was drawn to poetry, and I began to study the haftarah--the weekly selection from the prophets. As I grew busier, I began to appreciate time away from the world. Services became a refuge. I did not need to rest when I was a child, because I did not work. I did not want to come inside, because the outside world was still entirely beautiful to me.

More like this

Like something ripped bleeding from headline news, Intuition (2006, Dial Press) by Allegra Goodman is a timely story about scientific fraud. Even though the pivotal point of the story is one event, it is Goodman's careful and empathetic exploration of the relationships between the researchers and…
I recently finished reading Intuition, by Allegra Goodman. It's a great novel, and anyone who's done time as a postdoc will appreciate it, especially if you've done time as postdoc in biomedical research. You may find yourself reading it and thinking that surely Goodman must have been spying upon…
The wonder of a good novel is the way it uncovers universals through particulars. Having just read Allegra Goodman's Intuition, I was struck by the way her descriptions of a fictional molecular biology lab seemed to describe every molecular biology lab. Or is it just that every lab really looks the…
I'm teaching a course on Greek and Roman mythology this semester and last week we tackled this question: Did the Greeks believe their myths? That is indeed the title of a 1988 book by French historian Paul Veyne. He writes in his Introduction: Did the Greeks believe in their mythology? The answer…

You might want to say it was her "most recent" novel. I certainly hope it's not her last. :)

By June Blender (not verified) on 06 Jun 2008 #permalink

In one way or another we are all so effected by our religious upbringing. I experienced an obsessive-compulsive inundation as a child that brought about a quandary in adulthood as to how to present religion to my children. The concept of hell has certainly provided a plethora of challenges and intrigue for artists historically as they
helped construct it visually. It does not belong in the
minds of my children except as : illustration.

I am trying to introduce them to reasons for religious ritual in history and the varieties in different cultures.
I don't think the path taken matters, as long as an inner discovery of ourselves is attained and embraced - thereby
giving us a sense of psychological peace we all need, especially at the most challenging moments in life. I like
to listen to their interpretations and thoughts.

By Lee Pirozzi (not verified) on 09 Jun 2008 #permalink