Is the US homicide rate high only because of big cities?

Larry Cipriani said:

Well, if we nuke New York, Washington D.C., Los Angeles, and Detroit the
crime rates in the US will be incredibly low, lower than that of just about
every other nation on earth.

Not so. I have grouped together Chicago, Houston, Los Angeles, New
York, Philadelphia and Washington DC. (1998 figures)

        Pop Homicid Robbery Motor Vehicle  Theft
Big US Cities   17.7M   25.2    938 1587
Rest of US  228.1M  7.1 165 505
US Total    245.8M  8.4 221 583

For comparison, here is Australia, (grouping Sydney and Melbourne)

Syd+Mel     6.6M    2.0 85  1116
Rest of OZ  10.2M   2.0 30  544
OZ total    16.8M   2.0 52  770

and some other countries

Canada          2.0 94  344
New Zealand     2.6 41  999
England & Wales     1.2 62  728
West Germany        4.1 47  114
(West German homicide rate includes attempts)

US violent crime rates are far higher than other countries, even
excluding large cities.

What does that say about those cities ?
They are crime ridden cesspools is what. They also have some of the
strongest gun control laws in the US.

Which suggests that high crime rates cause gun control laws.

European gov'ts are now allowing [or are they back to disallowing]
immigration into their countries from poorer nations. We'll see how
long it takes for those crime rates to match ours.

Are you suggesting that it is immigrants that cause all those those
crimes?

Australia has had a higher (per-capita) immigration rate than the US
for many years.

More like this

Look in "Experiences of Crime across the World" van Dijk, Mayhew and Killias (1991). This reports the result of an international victimisation survey in the US, Canada, Australia and 11 European countries. Danny Low said: The last time I looked at an atlas, the world included places like Mexico…
Viktor writes: Of course, we know here in America that the highest crime rates for the past 50 years are in the cities that have the strictest gun control laws (Washington, D.C., New York City, Chicago, Detroit) imposed on innocent people - the distinction being, there can be no gun control that is…
We've been around on this before, and all it does is impress me with the predilection of some pro-gun folks for self-delusion on this topic. (I'm sorry if that sounds harsh, but it seems to me that many people suspend their powers of reason on this issue.) Here are the NSW homicide rates from 1910…
Gary Strand said: 'Twould seem that the difference between Australia's gun laws and the US' gun laws have no effect on suicide rates, since the numbers are nearly identical. By the same reasoning, you can conclude that Australia's more restrictive gun laws are the reason for the lower homicide…