Are the reductions in homicide following the introduction of gun control statistically significant?

Frank Crary said (referring to changes in homicide rate in NSW and Qld):

The sharp drop you claim to see, is (in my opinion) not significant compared
to the background variations. While this may have been real effect of gun
control laws, in is at least as likely that it is a coincidence.

Could the changes be caused by noise? This calls for a t test, to see
if the average homicide rate changed.

The significant events were:
1920: NSW controls all guns
1927: Queensland controls handguns and NSW drops controls on long guns

So, I took three groups of years 1911-1920 (pre-control), 1921-1927
(NSW controls, no Qld controls), 1928-1937 (both controls)

The means:

           NSW  Qld
1911-1920  2.3  4.1
1921-1927  1.4  4.3
1928-1937  1.6  2.7

Probability chance could cause the change:
In NSW between 11-20 and 21-27: 0.0003
In NSW between 21-27 and 28-37: 0.09
In Qld between 11-20 and 21-27: 0.57
In Qld between 21-27 and 28-37: 0.002

Both states recorded significant declines in the homicide rate
following gun control. If some other factor caused the declines, then
it did not operate in both states simultaneously. (The change in NSW
after 1927 is of borderline significance, but it was an increase.)


More like this

Could the changes be caused by noise? This calls for a t test, to see if the average homicide rate changed. Andy Freeman said: There's an interesting thing about averages. If you take the average of a declining series and compare it to the end point, you find that the average is, not surprisingly…
In a previous posting I observed that the homicide rate in New South Wales fell dramatically following the introduction of gun controls in 1920. Here, again, is the graph showing the homicide rate in NSW from 1900-1977. (Vertical scale is homicide rate per 100 000 population) 3 * 2.8 2.6…
Frank Crary said: In an effort to clear up this statistical game, I'm posting a detailed comparison of Mr. Lambert's and my models of the crime rate in New South Wales, between 1910 and 1930. The data, taken from the graph he posted on the 15th of this month, is: [Numbers deleted] (Please correct…
I decided to check the claim that crime went up following gun control in England in 1920. I compared the homicide rates for England for the period 1911-1920 with the period 1921-1930 and found that the rate declined by 8%. This change could have been caused by demographic changes that followed…