J. Neil Schulman writes:

So this data has been peer-reviewed by a top criminologist in this
country who was prejudiced in advance against its results, and even
HE found the scientific evidence overwhelmingly convincing.

This is untrue. Wolfgang writes:

"The usual criticisms of survey research, such as that done by Kleck
and Gertz, also apply to their research. The problems of small
numbers and extrapolating from relatively small samples to the
universe are common criticisms of all survey research, including
theirs. I did not mention this specifically in my printed comments
because I thought that this was obvious; within the specific
limitations of their research is what I meant by a lack of criticism
methodologically."
(J of Criminal Law and Criminology 86:2 p617-8)

One of the limitations of survey research that Wolfgang considered too
obvious to be necessary to point out is there is no guarantee that all
respondents told the truth. Mr Schulman is perhaps unaware of this
fact.

Tags

More like this

Pursuant to the recent discussion on the safety of carrying guns, I thought I'd throw this on the table: According to this web page there are numerous studies demonstrating that increased firearms carrying decreases crime. The argument is being made that armed students will generally stop an…
Ray writes: Danny's obvious reading disability has not allowed him to read this when I posted it before. Maybe he can get a friend to read it to him this time: W A Collier writes: Ray, one question for you: If all these other folks including Marvin E. Wolfgang (widely acclaimed as a…
Ray wrote: They promise confidentiality, and back it up with a law that's at the top of every survey: "NOTICE: Your report to the Census Bureau is confidential by law (US Code 42, Sections 3789g and 3735). All identifiable information will be used only by persons engaged in and for the purposes of…
J. Neil Schulman writes: If you start a survey by asking "Have you ever been a crime victim?" and do not survey people who answer NO because (a) their DGU prevented them from being damaged so they don't think of themselves as victims, therefore they are telling the truth but don't get counted AND…