A couple of interesting things about the Mary Rosh postings. First, in her book review Mary Rosh refers to "Professor Lott". At that time he was a John M. Olin Fellow at Chicago and certainly not a professor. In another post she claims that he was a chaired professor at Wharton. You can check Lott's resume and see that he was an assistant professor at Wharton and did not hold a chair.
skippy also has a few comments.