Day One of Roberts Confirmation Hearings

Well, day one is in the books. It consisted mostly of each member of the committee attempting to feign erudition while reading a script no doubt lovingly prepared by one of their staffers. The opening statements of each of the judiciary committee members has the primary purpose of allowing the Senators to stirke a pose for the various interest groups they represent. The secondary purpose is to test the nominee's ability to sit motionless and pretend to be paying attention for hours on end. In that regard, some are already criticizing Roberts for smiling unduly as one Senator praised his record and for looking shifty while another blathered on endlessly.

Ironically, the best advice Roberts has gotten about the nomination process came from the dreaded and vile Robert Bork, who told him publicly that he must resist the temptation to laugh when the Senators demonstrate their utter ignorance of legal matters. He did at least avoid doing that. One impressive thing is that Roberts delivered a 7 minute opening statement himself without notes.

More like this

Just noticed this very odd response by Mark Olson to my post about Robert Bork's mythical martyrdom. Much of the rhetoric in Olson's response would serve as a perfect example of how to execute the strategy known as poisoning the well, as he puts his own unique characterizations on events and…
Randy Barnett, my favorite legal scholar, has written an interesting essay on John Roberts and what his nomination says about the entire process. His take: But what sort of Justice will Judge Roberts make? I have no idea. I have never met him, so all I have to go on is his public record--a record…
Given a night to sleep on it and a bit more research, here are my initial thoughts on the nomination of John Roberts for the Supreme Court. First, let me note that there are different meanings to the word "conservative" in this context. Robert Bork, Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, Michael…
The hearings on the nomination of John Roberts as Chief Justice began at noon today. I've watched a few of the opening statements from the judiciary committee members and found much to laugh at. I'm hoping the full text of those remarks will be available in the next couple days so I can go over…