More on "Theistic Rationalism" and the Founders

Jon Rowe has another post up about the Founding Fathers and theistic rationalism, a subject on which he and I have both written a good deal. It includes a long quote from Gregg Frazer, a historian who did his dissertation on that subject and is the man who invented the term as a description of the views of 8 leading framers of the Declaration and the Constitution (Jefferson, Madison, Franklin, Adams, Washington, Hamilton, Morris and Wilson).

It is interesting to note that Frazer himself is a theologically conservative Christian, so much so that he believes in a literal 6 day creation. All the more credit to him, then, for bucking the "Christian nation" party line that is so common among others who share his philosophical view. He rightly corrects both sides in the founding fathers disputes, those who claim that all of the founders were Christian and those who claim that they were deists. Having spent the better part of 20 years exploring the views of those men, I've never come across a more apt description of their genuine views than Frazer's.

And coincidentally, yesterday was James Madison's birthday.

Tags

More like this

Jon Rowe has an excellent post up about religion and the founding fathers, stemming from a book review at the Claremont website. I very much like the phrase "theistic rationalism", which he quotes the book review as coining. That's an excellent description of the religious views of men like…
I was busy yesterday with other things, so I sent this post to Jon Rowe to give it the good fisking it deserves. He obliged. In short, Dembski attempted, weakly. to answer Judge Jones' statements about the founding fathers making reason the arbiter of religious claims. His answer didn't really…
There is a fascinating exchange going on over at Positive Liberty between Jon Rowe, Jim Babka and Gregg Frazer. There are two questions under consideration - to what extent is Calvinism opposed to revolution and to the notion of political rights in general; and on a larger level, does the Bible…
Jon Rowe has another excellent essay on the role of religion among the founding fathers. He draws on an op-ed piece by Mark Lilla in the NY Times on the same subject. Lilla rightly hammers the "schlock history written by religious propagandists like David Barton" while pointing to more serious…

He definitely can't get enough of that topic.

It is interesting to note that Frazer himself is a theologically conservative Christian [...]. All the more credit to him, then, for bucking the "Christian nation" party line that is so common among others who share his philosophical view.

The usual marks of a true professional historian. They seem to go extinct nowadays (this guy is old, right?) and become replaced by rabid ideologues or people writing books with sales in mind.

By Roman Werpachowski (not verified) on 17 Mar 2006 #permalink

Roman-

Frazer is not old. In fact, I think he's quite young. I just think that trait is rare in any age. All the more reason to praise his objectivity.

Frazer's pic and mini bio can be seen HERE. Doesn't appear to be an old fogey to me.

I happen to know that Frazer is 50 years old, as of February, 2006. You can decide for yourself whether that's old or not.

By the way, thanx for the kudos.

By Gregg Frazer (not verified) on 17 Jul 2006 #permalink