Here's Jack Balkin's analysis of Judge Taylor's ruling in the NSA warrantless wiretapping lawsuit. He likes the outcome, doesn't like the rationale and isn't sure it will survive an appeal. I tend to agree with him.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
There's also lots of interesting debate going on around the legal blogosphere concerning Judge Taylor's recent ruling in the NSA lawsuit. Orin Kerr raises some interesting questions in a post at Volokh. He points out something that concerned me as well when I first read the ruling. I was not…
I often agree with Glenn Greenwald on constitutional questions, but I think he's out to lunch in this post, where he criticizes those who criticized Judge Taylor's ruling in the NSA lawsuit. Many legal scholars have criticized many aspects of the ruling, and I think rightfully so. Personally, I…
Before I ever read the STACLU response to yesterday's ruling by Judge Taylor, I could easily predict two things:
1. They would declare her an evil, activist, terrorist-loving liberal demon.
2. They would either misunderstand or misrepresent the ruling.
Just call me Nostradamus. Here's John…
Editor's Note: Dan Ray left this as a comment on the thread below, but it's so long and detailed that I think it deserves to be up here on its own where everyone can read it. Dan is a law professor and a longtime reader who has become a friend as well and I have extended an invitation for him to be…