1. dispatches
  2. ADF Sues New York Over Pension Benefits for Gays

ADF Sues New York Over Pension Benefits for Gays

By stcynic on September 16, 2006.

The ADF has filed suit in state court in New York over the state's public employee pension fund recognizing gay marriages performed elsewhere.

In 2004, NY Attorney General Elliot Spitzer issued a legal opinion stating that the New York is obligated to recognize same-sex marriages performed in areas where same-sex marriages are legal.

New York State Comptroller Alan G. Hevesi followed that with a directive that the New York State Retirement System would respect legal out-of-state marriages between same-sex couples for the purposes of pension benefits.

The ADF is arguing that since the state Supreme Court of New York has upheld the state's ban on gay marriage, any recognition of gay marriages from out of state for any purpose is illegal. Whether that's a winning case in court really depends on the exact ruling, which I've not bothered to read in any detail.

Tags
Gay Rights

More like this

ADF and Gay Marriage Amendments
Man, the ADF is really on a roll lately with false claims. In this blog post, the admin of their blog claims that the various state amendments banning gay marriage do not interfere with governments or private companies offering benefits to domestic partners: Preying on these and similar fears,…
Thomas More Law Center Sues MSU
Continuing their crusade to insure that gay couples are punished as much as possible for being gay, the Thomas More Law Center has sued Michigan State University over their policy of providing health care benefits to gay couples employed by the university. This is the second such lawsuit the TMLC…
Judge Wilkinson on Gay Marriage Amendments
Color me surprised after reading this op-ed by Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson. Long considered one of the most conservative judges on the Federal bench, he has been on virtually every short list for a Supreme Court nomination since 2001. Yet he comes out against both state and federal constitutional…
ADF Reaction to New Jersey Ruling
The ADF immediately put out a press release after yesterday's ruling on gay marriage from the New Jersey Supreme Court. It was a very strange statement. The title declares, NJ high court hands loss to marriage opponents. Then they spend most of the press release complaining about how bad the ruling…