A Marine Officer Writes Home

More like this

From Linda Holmes, a poignant post about how the deluge of information makes it impossible to scratch the surface in a single lifetime: there are really only two responses if you want to feel like you're well-read, or well-versed in music, or whatever the case may be: culling and surrender. Culling…
Here's the latest carnivalia for you to enjoy; Book Review blog carnival, 14th edition. If you skim this carnival quickly, you will notice that the vast majority of books that are being reviewed here has always been and continues to be non-fiction works. (Kinda interesting, methinks). Everything…
I was chatting with my much younger brother recently and he mentioned an interest in philosophy. I asked if he'd read Plato, and he returned my query with a question: "Is Plato worth reading?" My own answer: I don't think Plato is really worth reading, but, many thinkers have disagreed and Plato…
Those of you with long memories may recall that I was on the jury for the 2009 Sunburst Award for Canadian Literature of the Fantastic. Well, the names of the winners have just been released: Adult: The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson Young Adult: Little Brother by Cory DoctorowYou can check out the…

In another thread SharonB said:

in today's environment, when you arrive at field grade rank, your oath to uphold the Constitution morphs into an oath to support and defend the Fuehrer, it seems.

I'd put money that the guy writing this email is a field grade MI. Major minimally, perhaps LtCol.

I'm very interested in the judicious omissions mentioned in the intro.

A former student of mine is an Army officer in Iraq. His experience is not as stark as the account in Time, but he's had a bellyful of seeing his men unable to do their jobs because they're required to stand aside (in a kind of guard duty), while very expensive civilian contractors do the support tasks the soldiers were trained to do. It's a Pentagon pig trough over there for well-connected military contractors. My student recently wrote to say he hopes to be home soon. He can't wait.

check washington monthly's blog by kevin drum he says the author is marine col. pete devlin

Ted:
Funny thing. I was a MAJ in MI (35C), US Army. Never in a real hot - war zone, just the cold kind.

The guys at the pointy end of the spear are a band of brothers (and sisters). But the guys in the Polygon (aka, Puzzle Palace) and probably a lot of them in the Green Zone, are a different breed. All generals are politicians, that's both good and bad. Good in that you need to be politically astute, bad because it breeds careerism.

This Col. Devlin is probably toast. A bright and shining lie is required to make BG. He obviously cares more for his troops and telling it like it is, than he does for getting ahead.

I would follow a man like that into hell itself. Not many of them make it to the top.

The writer's candor blows the socks of back office analysts back home. Would that all our commanders were as observant and level headed. I also noted the comment on that tired cliché about athiests, but rich beat me to it. 'Nough said.