On my random speculations

Chaiten Ash

Before we get too far, I wanted to make sure that folks understand that I'm just making educated conjectures on the nature of the eruptions I read about and by no means do I have any extra insight over those scientists on the ground at the eruption. I have a very limited set of data to examine - whatever the media reports - so I am just speculating based on what I know about the eruption style, volcano in question and whatever other variables might come into play. So, please, don't think that I know exactly what is going on or what will happen better than the scientists tackling the volcano firsthand.

That being said, I might not be a big fan of Donald Rumsfeld, but he does divide things up nicely when it comes to assessing a situation, so here we go.

For Volcan Chaiten:

Known knowns: The volcano has been erupting for the past week; large ash column up to possibly as high as 90,000 feet (!); thick ash deposits (>30 cm) out 10s of km from the vent; potentially lava extrusion at the vent; no pyroclastic flows, no lahars (so far); two discrete vents have coalesced into one vent; upwards of 2 cubic kilometers of erupted material (thus far); last known eruption at Chaiten was 7450 BC, or roughly 9,500 years ago.

Unknown knowns: How long will the eruption last?; how long until the supply rate of pyroclastic material from the vent drops below the rate needed to keep the ash column aloft?; when the ash column collapses, how big will the pyroclastic flows be?; will lahars begin to be generated?; will the volcanic edifice collapse due to the eruption? if so, will there be pyroclastic flows generated by the collapse and/or ring vents forming?; is this the main eruption or will things get bigger? how much lava will be extruded at the main vents? will more vents open?; how long until people can get near the vent to see what has occured firsthand?

Unknown unknowns: Well, I can't really speculate of these, now can I?

At least we know that Chaiten spared the berry crops!

More like this

Chaiten in Chile erupting in January 2009. Even after over a year of activity, Eruptions readers are still captivated by the volcano. Thanks for sending me your questions about volcanoes and volcanism. I'll try to tackle some hear - but as always, keep the questions coming! Send them to For those…
This marks a full week of eruption at Chaiten and the volcano shows no signs of abating. You have to feel for Luis Lara. He is apparently the pointman for the SERNAGEOMIN in regards to this eruption and really, I think its anybody's guess what might happen next. Heck, we haven't seen many…
Another day, another development at Chaiten. Military stationed near the volcano helping with evacuations reported "booming noises" and saw incandescent blocks getting hurled from the vent area. This suggests that lava is at the surface and potentially that the edifice itself is beginning to…
Back in the days when Eruptions was on Wordpress, I held a vote about what volcano should be the next to be profiled on this blog. The winner was Mt. Hood in Oregon, and after much waiting, the profile is here. I will actually be out of town until Monday doing some house shopping in this little…