1. gnxp
  2. In search of rare variants

In search of rare variants

By razib on April 20, 2009.

In response to the NEJM issue on personal genomics and the CDCV hypothesis, p-ter offers a proposal:

Let's follow Goldstein's back-of-the-envelope calculations: assume there are ~100K polymorphisms (assuming Goldstein isn't making the mistake I attribute to him, this includes polymorphisms both common and rare) that contribute to human height, that we've found the ones that account for the largest fractions of the variance, and that these fractions of variance follow an exponential distribution.

Now, assume you have assembled a cohort of 5000 individuals and done a genome-wide association study using common SNPs. You find some interesting things, but you want more. Now, you have two choices: sequence those 5000 individuals to look for rarer variation, or increase sample size to 20,000 and perform another association study using the same set of common polymorphisms.

Read the whole thing.

Tags
genetics
Common disease-common variant hypothesis
David Goldstein
genetic variation
Medical Genetics

More like this

Genome-wide association studies: failure or success?
The latest issue of the New England Journal of Medicine has four excellent and thought-provoking articles on the recent revolution in the genetics of common disease and its implications for personalised medicine and personal genomics. Razib and Misha Angrist have already commented, and there's…
David Goldstein on the failures of genome-wide association studies
The genome-wide association study has been the technique du jour in human genetics for much of the last two years. It's a pure brute force approach, surveying up to a million sites of common variation throughout the genomes of thousands of people at a time, some of whom suffer from a particular…
Two new pigmentation papers
A Genome-Wide Association Study Identifies Novel Alleles Associated with Hair Color and Skin Pigmentation:It has been a longstanding hypothesis that human pigmentation is tightly regulated by genetic variation. However, very few genes have been identified that contain common genetic variants…
Genetics of gene expression in African-Americans: ominous news for personal genomics?
I was planning to write a long article on this recent paper in PLoS Genetics, but p-ter at Gene Expression and G at Popgen ramblings have both covered the central message very well. So if you haven't read those articles, already, go and do so now - when you come back, I want to talk about the…