Astronomical madness

By hrynyshyn on August 24, 2006.

I envy Nature reporter Jenny Hogan, who's been blogging from the International Astronomical Union's big meeting in Prague for the past couple of weeks. I've always considered science journalism the most fascinating sector of the industry (that's why I'm one), but Hogan appears to be having an unusually fun time as the conference delegates lose their calm, rational demeanor in favor of an obsessive, impulsive approach to redefining the planets.

Her latest post, made just a few hours ago, has a breathless quality to it:

IAU: invasion!

What a madhouse. I was skipping down the stairs of the conference centre on my way to a 10.30am interview (not about planets) when I encountered a charge of scientists led by the esteemed Brian Marsden. "You're the press," one of his cohort noticed. "Show us to the press room."

I retraced my steps. Marsden had, for many years, been responsible for cataloguing asteroids and other lumps of rock in his role as the head of the Minor Planet Center. He retired recently *, but made the invasion of the press room with youthful vigour. The battalion had an announcement to make.

Read the rest of the madness here.

[UPDATE: There are only Eight (8) Planets! Pluto Demoted to "Dwarf" Status]

Tags
Science Culture

More like this

Why is Pluto not a planet?
Short answer: Pluto has only two of the three necessary characteristics to be called a planet. Pluto has not cleared its neighborhood, or orbit. But, of course, there are additional details. The simplest reason that Pluto is not a planet is that planet experts say so, and this is their job. But…
A Matter of Definition
Like the Indiana Pi Bill before it, the Illinois Legislature's attempt to weigh in on the planetary status of Pluto is kind of silly. But not so silly as you might think. The Indiana Pi Bill in popular legend was an attempt to bring the stubborn decimal expansion of pi into accord with the…
Pluto: STFU already!
So... is Pluto really a Planet? IAU Press Release 01/99 February 3, 1999 Recent news reports have given much attention to what was believed to be an initiative by the International Astronomical Union (IAU) to change the status of Pluto as the ninth planet in the solar system. Unfortunately, some…
Happy 80th Birthday, Pluto!
We used to think Pluto was a misfit. -Alan Stern Eighty years ago, we solidly had eight planets in the Solar System: the same eight we have now. But in the late 1920s, a young astronomer was looking up at the sky, night after night, searching for tiny moving objects that could possibly be planets…

I am personally getting tired of all this beuracracy. It is a planet, no it is not, yes it is... These same scientists debating whether or not it is indeed a planet, should have spent that time on something else, like actual observing, and research. What does it matter whether or not we call it a dwarf planet? If there are are more objects out there the same or larger than pluto, that orbit the sun, we can begin calling them dwarf planets, but the amount of debate around one descolate planet is just rediculous.