Today's New York Times Science section includes coverage of a forum on the religion-science wars this month at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in La Jolla, Calif. Just about everybody who's anybody in this battle was there. My favorite quote comes from Steve Weinberg: "Anything that we scientists can do to weaken the hold of religion should be done and may in the end be our greatest contribution to civilization."
That's quite a thing to say -- it's not the medical advances, and understanding of our place in the universe, or our kinship with all other species that will define science, but simply getting rid of superstition. Hmmm.
But there's also this great little exchange between Weinberg and Richard Dawkins:
Before he left to fly back home to Austin, Dr. Weinberg seemed to soften for a moment, describing religion a bit fondly as a crazy old aunt.
"She tells lies, and she stirs up all sorts of mischief and she's getting on, and she may not have that much life left in her, but she was beautiful once," he lamented. "When she's gone, we may miss her."
Dr. Dawkins wasn't buying it. "I won't miss her at all," he said. "Not a scrap. Not a smidgen."
Read the whole thing. It's worth it. I wish I was there.
- Log in to post comments
I won't miss her at all. She smells of mothballs, fear, stale urine and death.
A crazy old aunt with a chainsaw and an arsenal of automatic weapons.
Uhm.... Let's see. May I present one Sir Isaac Newton? Anyone alive right now got the balls to go head to head with him in ANY Scientific forum? Anywhere, anytime? Nah, didn't think so.
And yet, he saw himself a Christian. A devout one, if memory serves. He seemed to strike a fair balance.
And we gotta think that inventing calculus was a decent contribution to the human condition.
Maybe that aunt ain't so bad after all...
I'm game. You'll have to find his head first, though.
Or maybe attributing any good thing any religious person does to their religion is a bit nuts.
I found it! Getting permission to dig it up might be bothersome.
I'll take the sane grandmother who was not afraid to live life, rather than the crazy old aunt who smelled of cats.
In Isaac Newtons time, how many Europeans were not Christian of some sort? Seems to me that people who weren't were second class (or lower), or else killed. Not exactly a sterling example. Does anyone wonder what old Isaac would believe now that we know more about the world?
I think it's impossible to know, given the incentive to stay in the closet for reasons expressed in your next sentence.
That is interesting to contemplate, but I wouldn't use it in an argument with Creationists. I get really annoyed when the after-death conversions get applied in the opposite direction.
It's especially embarrassing when the crazy old aunt spell. Theocrats in Dixie County, Florida placed a large stone monument with the 10 commandments on the courthouse steps. Commandment #7 is THOU SHALT NOT COMMIT ADULTRY.
Religion is like a crazy old uncle.
He burns books of science; he locks the birth control cabinet; he hires gay prostitutes and takes illegal drugs; he forces 14 year old girls to marry old men; he's murdered millions of innocent people and he still supports massive wars.
He may not have that much life left in him, he wasn't beautiful, and when he's gone, only a psychopathic or delusional idiot should miss him.