Carl Zimmer on non-Seinfeldian shrinkage in fossilized fish brain

Carl explains this:

After death, brains that do not simply disappear sometimes get smaller. In this particular fish, Sibyrhynchus denisoni the brain must have gotten a lot smaller. Check out this image, in which the braincase is in red, and the brain is in yellow. (The scale bar is 5 millimeters.)

The subject is a paper in PNAS that's available to journalists but no one else so far, yet not still embargoed ... a policy I sort of like for selfish reasons but still can't figure out. This means this link to the paper won't work for a few more days. Paper is on a 3M-year-old fossilized brain, the oldest yet found, and Carl first wrote it up yesterday in a nice post in which he included this flashy movie showing the skull as revealed by synchrotron holotomography, which is a sort of holographic imaging technique that, as you can see, produces some great images:

Carl's post today, which runs the less-flashy figures at top of this post. addresses more directly the shrinkage issue,. Though brief it's quite intriguing, as some argue that the size mismatch was all shrinkage, but one scientist raises the possibility that the fish's brain never really filled the cavity. See the comments for the first post for more on that.)

And I like his take-home:

Why there would be such a mismatch between brain size and braincase size the scientists can't yet say. Which is all the more reason, as Pierre Kerner points out in the comments, for paleontologists to start opening museum drawers and do some more scanning. Let's see what pattern emerges.

There's a lot of data in specimen cabinets around the world, waiting to be revealed with judicious use cutting-edge analysis like this imaging. So go to it.

Which is to say -- and I'm not sure how to say this politely: There's not nearly enough opening of old drawers in science these days.

More like this

... has been found. Inside the fish's skull, in fact. This is from a chimaeroid fish, which today are fairly rare but during the Carboniferoius were quite common and diverse. There are really two aspects of this find that are especially interesting. One is the 3D imagery that was obtained of…
Nervous tissue is extremely fragile, and so is very well protected. The brain, which has a jelly-like consistency, is encased in the skull, and is surrounded by cerebrospinal fluid, which acts to cushion it against blows that might cause it to come into contact with the inside of its bony case.…
tags: researchblogging.org, archaeopteryx, dinosaurs, mammals, fossils Archaeopteryx fossil showing the distinctive head-back death pose of many articulated fossilized birds, dinosaurs and early mammals. Archaeopteryx is an ancient feathered dinosaur. This specimen is at the Humboldt Museum,…
Well. Raising a holy hullabaloo on the internet pays dividends. Vincent Perrichot, one of the authors on the contested PNAS paper, has sent along another aspect of the mystery fossil: Having trouble?  I've arranged a Formica specimen to model the pose: In the comments below, Vincent provides his…