Misdiagnosing the live and the dead

autopsy

"One in six patients 'wrongly diagnosed by NHS doctors'," shouts the Daily Mail (via EvidenceMatters. This should not surprise us: Autopsies have been finding a similar percentage of misdiagnosis among the dead for decades. Doctors will always miss some diagnoses. Progress is a matter of ever narrowing the list of things doctors miss -- so the other problems can be diagnosed and treated, letting the patients live longer (till they did of something incurable -- or something we still haven't learned to diagnose. Learn to properly diagnose, say, appendicitis, and you can save the life of a10-year-old (as I was when I had my appendix out) and let him die decades later of old age, something incurable -- or something the doctor misses then.

Hard to accept that doctors miss things. They always will. The shame is that they so often miss things and then bury the mistakes -- as they do now about 10-15% of the time. Doing so removes the opportunity to learn from the mistake and save the patient from the same one.

More like this

This thread needed to be moved up for obvious reasons. Have at it. --PalMD I've been writing quite a bit about "questionable" illnesses, shameless quacks and the like, but there are reasons that people seek out odd diagnoses and cult doctors. They feel crappy, and they haven't yet found someone…
photo: Philip Todeldano for the New York Times Part of any real healthcare reform will be improving practices in hospitals, and -- as Obama's proposed commission on comparative effectiveness would do -- identifying what works and what doesn't. Knowing what works and why people get better or not…
I can't tell you the number of people who complain to me about having their hope taken away. Exactly what this means, though, isn't always clear. Sometimes an oncologist will tell them (so they say) that they have a month to live. Sometimes their cardiologist tells them (so they say) not to…
What could be more important than a good old-fashioned flame war? I'll get to that in a moment, so please stick with me. The recent imbroglio between some of our doctor bloggers and non-physician scientists got me thinking (so it couldn't be all bad). As a quick summary, PhysioProf of the…