1. pharyngula
  2. We don't have a single mind, we have a series of fabulator modules

We don't have a single mind, we have a series of fabulator modules

By pharyngula on September 22, 2010.

Everyone should read this very good, very clear article in Seed magazine. It stomps on the concept of a soul from the perspective of modern neuroscience.

The evidence supports another view: Our brains create an illusion of unity and control where there really isn't any. Within the wide range of works arranged along the axis of soulism, from Life After Death: The Evidence, by Dinesh D'Souza, to Absence of Mind, by Marilynne Robinson, it is clear there is very little understanding of the brain. In fact, to advance their ideas, these authors have to be almost completely unaware of neurology and neuroscience. For example, Robinson tells us, "Our religious traditions give us as the name of God two deeply mysterious words, one deeply mysterious utterance: I AM." The translation might be, "indoctrination tells us we have a soul, it feels like we are a unified little god in control of our bodies, so we are."

It's all illusions, all the way through.

Tags
neurobiology

More like this

D'Souza vs. Hitchens
Another day, another debate between Christopher Hitchens and a defender of the faith. This time it was Dinesh D'Souza. The video of the procedings can be found here. It was a frustrating debate. Through most of it I felt D'Souza and Hitchens were talking about different things. Hitchens focused…
Another unpleasant discharge from the disreputable Terry Lectures
What is it with some English professors and their contempt for science? Some of the noisiest, most obnoxious, most self-indulgently prolix and goofy critics of the New Atheism are full-of-themselves pomposities like Eagleton and Fish, and now we can apparently add another, Marilynne Robinson. She's…
Conservative Thought = Anti-Atheism Thought
At least, that is the conclusion you would inevitably come to if you read Town Hall on a regular basis. The wesbite that boasts of being the first conservative web community seems to have a yen for anti-atheist propaganda. For example, here's Mike Adams in a column entitled, “Understanding Atheism…
Stupidity, Human Nature, and Ordinary Kindness.
PZ Myers has an article up calling attention to a recent article by "conservative scholar" and Hoover Institution fellow Dinesh D'Souza. D'Souza, in his opinion piece, wonders where the atheists go when bad things happen. As "evidence" for the missing atheists, D'Souza points out that Richard…