A Many Worlds Puzzle of a Different Kind

Fortune has put out its list of the top 100 companies to work for. The Google Monster is number one. Washington state does pretty good, as it is in a tie for fourth in the total number of companies on the list with headquarters in the state. (Per capita it comes in third, losing to Delaware and D.C.)

Looking through their article on "10 fascinating Googlers" I found Wei-Hwa Huang. Hey, he was in my class at Caltech! Indeed Wei-Hwa was responsible for one of my favorite stories about the many-worlds interpretation of quantum theory. Huh?

Wei-Hwa, you see, is a world class puzzle solver (he was a world puzzle champion while I was at Caltech.) One day I was sitting with a friend (a fellow physicist who lost on Jeopardy) on the Olive Walk at Caltech, enjoying the wonderful California weather, when a man approached us with one of those wood and string puzzles where you try to take the puzzle apart. While we played with the puzzle the guy talked with us. Turns out he was looking for Wei-Hwa. Okay, nothing strange there: he had a puzzle, and Wei-Hwa was the guy to go to for that. Then we asked him why he wanted to see Wei-Hwa. He told us that when he was a child he had this very puzzle that we were playing with. And when he was a kid he remembers that he could solve the puzzle. But now, for the life of him, he couldn't figure out how to solve the puzzle.

"So," we said, "you want to have Wei-Hwa show you how to solve the puzzle?"

"No, he said, "what I really want is for Wei-Hwa to show that solving the puzzle is impossible. Because then that would prove the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics!"

At which point my fellow physicist and I quickly gave the puzzle back to the man and quickly made haste for fear he might start really raving.

More like this

Phillip Ball has a long aggrieved essay about the Many-Worlds Interpretation, which is, as Sean Carroll notes, pretty bad. Ball declares that Many-Worlds is "incoherent, both philosophically and logically," but in fact, he's got this exactly backwards: Many-Worlds is, in fact, a marvel of logical…
This is the alst week of the academic term here, so I've been crazy busy, which is my excuse for letting things slip. I did want to get back to something raised in the comments to the comments to the Born rule post. It's kind of gotten buried in a bunch of other stuff, so I'll promote it to a full…
One of my pet peeves about people and math is that most people don't really have a clue of what math is. I've been writing this blog for something over three years, and by the standards of a lot of people, I've almost never written about math. Yesterday, my son's kindergarten class had a picnic.…
There have been some good comments on last week's post about the Many-Worlds Interpretation, which I find a little surprising, as it was thrown together very quickly and kind of rant-y on my part, because I was annoyed by the tone of the original Phillip Ball article. (His follow-up hasn't helped…

So, in another world the puzzle was solvable and now, in this one, it is not. I hate when that happens!

By JohnQPublic (not verified) on 23 Jan 2008 #permalink

I know how that guy feels. I used to live in an alternate quantum state where I was gainfully and respectably employed. Then some weird-ass frippery happened and I found myself here.

Dave,

When you were at Tech, in which house did you live in? North Houses or South Houses? I would bet you were not at Ricketts ;-)

Is google still the best place to work if you want to work 9-5? I would doubt it.

Rod: Hey what are you saying about scurves? I was in Ruddock.

Dave,

I have nothing against Scurves. In fact, I lived at Ricketts for some time, and have pretty good memories from it :-)

Unsolvable 3-dimensional puzzle is key to spacetime? Right!

Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency, by Douglas Adams. It is described on its cover as a "thumping good detective-ghost-horror-whodunnit-time-travel-romantic-musical-comedy-epic".

Wikipedia summarizes one plot element:

"Richard MacDuff, lead software engineer for Way Forward Technologies II, has programmed his Apple computer to find out how to remove a stuck sofa from his flat's staircase. The computer says it is impossible to remove the sofa. Then, after Richard re-programs the application, the computer says it is impossible for the sofa to be wedged in its current position in the first place."

Not to be confused with the 2-dimensional Moving Sofa Problem, where MathWorld begins:

"What is the sofa of greatest area S which can be moved around a right-angled hallway of unit width? Hammersley (Croft et al. 1994) showed that
S >= pi/2 + 2/pi = 2.2074...

(Sloane's A086118). Gerver (1992) found a sofa with larger area and provided arguments indicating that it is either optimal or close to it. The boundary of Gerver's sofa is a complicated shape composed of 18 arcs...

Wei-Hwa Huang is cool. Dave Bacon is Cool. Caltech is cool. And this is invariant under permutation of undergraduate houses, an many of the many-worlds.

I was kidding, of course :) My grandfather was a scurv (I think all off campus people were scurvs...the houses were built while he attended Caltech.)

I know how that guy feels. I used to live in an alternate quantum state where I was gainfully and respectably employed. Then some weird-ass frippery happened and I found myself here.

Posted by: John McKay | January 23, 2008 2:10 PM

I know how you feel! The same thing happened to me! LOL!
Dave Briggs :~)