Christmas Quiz

Merry Christmas to all my readers, and even more to my writers. Here is a festive image, tastefully coloured in by me.

i-d91d5518993c93d4d6905cd98fab3f55-d-elf.jpg

And now for the quiz. In the spirit of "5 advances in climate science" I ask for the 5 best mistakes in sci-fi novels of the past year. To get the ball rolling with a low bar (and mix some metaphors in the process) I'll offer the polar orbiters in Anathem. Things like di-lithium crystals don't exist don't count, of course. It has to be something plausible and interesting thats wrong.

[Oh well, that didn't work. Never mind... -W]

More like this

I'm reading Anathem because Paul told me to. And because I'm enjoying it. And because its good and thick and will sustain lots of time. Read Paul's review if you're interested in an overview; I'm not going to do that, if only because I haven't finished it (I'm about half way through, if you care).…
Sometimes fractured energies in our planet's noosphere can throw people together who, logically, should never meet. There's no rational reason I should count among my friends the particularly reclusive, Cologne-based science fiction writer and critic Mark von Schlegell; but, lo, kismet, I do.…
“We do not realize what we have on Earth until we leave it.” -Jim Lovell Well, the Scienceblogs comments are still on the fritz, requiring me to manually un-spam them one-at-a-time, but Starts With A Bang! is still going strong with some fabulous stories based on the best knowledge we have! This…
I know I'm about a year late on this, but it was only recently that I finally watched the notorious Sci-Fi Channel version of Ursula K. LeGuin's Earthsea cycle. LeGuin has complained at length about how the adaptation destroyed her novels. I heartily agree. The Sci-Fi version simply invents, out of…

I like fantasy... but mainly because it is fantasy so I ignore all mistakes about how the "world" behaves... I have a hard time reading thrillers though... I hate when they start the CSI stuff and gets it wrong... or when the main persons just behave to irrational... :)