Rule #1: Giving Talks

[Data collection fortnight ends today. And then we shall return to our regularly scheduled programming. Until then, here's Rule #1, from the archives.]

If you are giving a talk, or teaching a class, or are otherwise responsible for transmitting content from your brain to other peoples' brains, you should be able to give that talk - even if somewhat modified - without any visual aids. You should be perfectly capable of giving that talk, in the dark, if the power goes out. Because your science is so awesome that your words alone will make people revere you like the science god or goddess that you are.

More like this

Bad teaching is one of my pet peeves, but I go back and forth on PowerPoint. I think its egregious abuse most of its users shouldn't necessarily bring a cloud on the whole program -- sometimes it is used effectively. Still most people are not using it correctly, in a way that facilitates good…
The Reveres are at the beach. It's not our natural habitat, but the generic Mrs. R. loves the beach so here we are. We often write in the morning (after emerging from our small flat in Hilbert space) but today we were otherwise occupied and then went to the beach and baked our brains out. Then we…
I unwisely agreed to cover the first class for one of my colleagues with a late-arriving flight back from break before finding out when the class met, which was 8:00 this morning. As a result, my whole morning blog routine was disrupted. I'm saved from having the site go completely dark, though, by…
Late Wednesday evening, a terrible disaster began to unfold in the ScienceBlogs universe: word emerged that a zombie attack was taking place in our bloggers' homes. While the attack was believed to have begun somewhere in the southeastern United States, with patient zero Scicurious, it has now…

One of the best talks I ever attended was given by paleontologist Gary Vermeij. Gary, being blind, doesn't need visuals to string together a compelling narrative.

Depends on the subject. Talks on geology are typically heavy on maps and diagrams that matter a lot. I've given up to hourlong power point presentations that had NO text slides aside from the title. Sometimes you just can't live without the pictures.

Also depends on the audience. A lecture class or a general audience, yes. (I was a student back in the chalkboard era, and there were good, dynamic lecturers back then.) An audience consisting of specialists in your field will want to see the data.

By Eric Lund (not verified) on 10 May 2010 #permalink