Editor's Selections: Death and Sex, Death and Football, Death and Chimpanzees

Here are my Research Blogging Editor's Selections for this week:

  • Let's start out with something particularly morbid (though potentially the best lede ever): "What effect do thoughts of death have on a typical person's desire for sex?" This fascinating post by Christian Jarrett of BPS Research Digest asks, when is death an aphrodisiac?
  • If death is an aphrodisiac, then tons of sex should be occurring in Pittsburgh right now, since When Your Super Bowl Team Goes Down, Your Death Risk Goes Up. David Berreby of Mind Matters explains.
  • I'm not sure why death is such a prominent theme this week, but this incredibly poignant post by Eric M. Johnson of The Primate Diaries (In Exile) is a must-read. He writes about a recent study in which researchers "documented a case where a chimpanzee mother faced what for most of us would be an unthinkable horror: the death of her child," and describes a potential non-human primate model for mourning.

More like this

Here are my Research Blogging Editor's Selections for this week: "Young children are little scientists. They instinctively stretch, prod, observe and categorise the world's offerings." Christian Jarrett at BPS Research Digest discusses how early children can be exposed to scientific ideas. Dr.…
Here are my Research Blogging Editor's Selections for this week: Christian Jarrett of BPS Research Digest starts us off with a big cup of coffee. Coffee helps women cope with stressful meetings but has the opposite effect on men. What's the point of music? Steven Pinker once famously remarked that…
Here are my Research Blogging Editor's Selections for this week: Ready for some more Thanksgiving science? Brad Walters of Cortical Hemming and Hawing asks what football can tell us about decision-making: Why you should always go for it on 4th and short. The Neurocritic reports a fascinating study…
Here are my Research Blogging Editor's Selections for this week. So much good stuff this week, it was hard to choose. But choose I must: To start us out, Dr. Sharma of his eponymous blog discusses a new finding in neuroscience: is there a gene that's associated with the so-called sweet tooth?…

Jason, I love your blog. I want to take issue with how you end this post, though--with that word "model." To me a model is a (relatively) simple representation of a natural process that allows us to better understand that process. Mathematical models allow us to reduce real, complex phenomena to common, understandable terms. A mouse model of cancer allows us to understand a real, complex disease process under simplified (genetic, experiential) conditions.

There is no model here--unless you want to make the claim, as many seem to, that chimpanzee behavior is really nothing but, or at least can usefully be considered as, simplified human behavior. It's not, of course. It's chimpanzee behavior.

Eric Johnson, in his great piece, has not described a potential non-human primate model of mourning. What Eric has described for us is an instance of actual chimpanzees actually mourning an actual, dead infant. This is real, complex behavior, freely employed by real, complex free-living individuals.

This is not a model of morning, it's an instance of mourning. Let us take at least a moment to appreciate it for what it is and not be too quick to pretend that chimpanzees are here as hairy test tubes with no interests but to better help us understand ourselves.

By Jason Wallin (not verified) on 09 Feb 2011 #permalink