What's that Smell?

Weizmann Institute scientists have created a “white smell.” Think about white light or white noise: Each mixes a bunch of different waves together from various parts of the visual or audible spectrum. Those wavelengths combine such that we perceive that unobtrusive light or sound we call “white.”

How do smells fit into this scenario? Prof. Noam Sobel and his group have already shown that smells have their own spectrum – ranging from pleasant to unpleasant – and that this relates to the chemical structure of the odor molecules. Is this spectrum truly analogous to that of light or sound? That is, can one take bits from different parts of that spectrum, mix them together and come up with a convergent stimulus?

It turns out that if you take enough different and varied scents – at least 30 – dilute them all to the close to the same intensity and mix them together, you can produce a white smell. That is, those who smell it will perceive it to be neither pleasant nor unpleasant. And like white light or white sound, the exact mix doesn’t really matter, as long as the range is large enough and the intensities similar. The research team mixed up various versions of the odor blend and, past 30 different scents, the subjects who smelled them thought they smelled the same.

Aside from possible applications in the odor neutralization industry, the findings, says Sobel, reveal something very fundamental about our sense of smell. According to him, the smells we perceive are more than just the sensations from a lot of different smell receptors added together -- but it turns out they can also be less. As in vision and hearing, the mechanical receptors in our sense organs are tuned to specific stimuli, but when all of those stimuli come together, the sum of our perception can be simply “white.”


More like this

The olfactory membranes in your nose are densely packed with smell receptors. These receptors come in some 400 different subtypes; complex odors like that of rose petals can waft around 175 distinct kinds of odor molecules in the direction of your nose. In other words, the number of discrete odors…
Taste is a notoriously difficult sense to study. My son Jim can't stand baked potatoes, but I can't get enough of them. I don't like watermelon, but the rest of my family gobbles it up. Even more perplexingly, I do like watermelon candy. With all the individual differences in taste, how can…
Occasionally you read a journal article so well-titled, you have to steal it for your blog post title. "Smells Like Clean Spirit" is a report by Rob Holland, Merel Hendricks, and Henk Aarts, in which they use smells to unconsciously modify their victims' participants' behavior. In some ways, this…
Wine expert Robert Parker claims to be able to distinguish every wine he has ever tasted—10,000 different wines a year—by taste alone. Winemakers can use their sense of smell to detect slight imbalances early in the wine production process that might lead to a spoiled batch. Meanwhile, novices walk…

interesting topics to read

This is really interesting given the relatively special nature of the sense of smell — it's a sensitivity to a very large number of specific molecules, not something closer to a general, abstracted physical phenomenon as in the case of hearing and vision. So you wouldn't necessarily expect there to be an analogous subjective experience as "whiteness".

That there is, hints at some of the tendencies in higher-level cognitive processing.

By Keith M Ellis (not verified) on 25 Nov 2012 #permalink

Howdy! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to take a look. I'm definitely loving the information. I'm bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Exceptional blog and fantastic style and design.

By Lululemon Sale (not verified) on 07 Jul 2013 #permalink