Subsidies and Small Farms

Another post related to the Science and the Farm Bill one.

i-d92cdf566a6f52a82a2c2c3d9600c0aa-From ASD.jpg

Image courtesy of Appalachian Sustainable Development (here)

Subsidies come in for a lot of debate. No controversy in saying that -- right wing, left-wing, top-wing, no wing. The controversy is about what the subsidies are for, who pays for them, who gets them, and what else we could've got with that money. It's here that you get a host of critiques about subsidies.

The Heritage Foundation, as we linked to before, is going to fight for reducing taxes under the cloak of fighting for taxpayer rights, not wanting their hard-inherited money to go to undeserving farmers. They interpret the subsidy as throwing money away, as giving to someone for doing nothing. You just can't be more morally contemptible, they'll say.

On another side, we hear from small farmers that the subsidies go to big agri-business, that they support the meanest, fiercest, most ecologically destructive industrial system over their small, local farms. This is the case made by Anthony Flaccavento, who had a small brief, "Hurting a Small Farm Near You," in Sunday's Washington Post, and who will be discussing the matter at washingtonpost.com today, Thursday, at noon. Flaccavento is the Executive Director of Appalachian Sustainable Development and a Food and Society Policy Fellow.

The new Farm Bill brings all of this out. I wonder how the conversation with Flaccavento will go. Someone should check it out and tell us.*

*You know, it said he'd be on-line in the newspaper, but I can't find mention of it anywhere at the Post's webpage.

More like this

There's quite an argument going on in the comments after my post yesterday about government crop quotas. Here's what I think those who disagree with me are missing: the government is doing what would be illegal if corporations did it. If oil companies got together and decided to all limit their…
The Miami-Herald is reporting today that food stamp use has more than doubled among Floridians in the last three years: More than 2.5 million Floridians are on food stamps, up from three years ago where 1.2 million residents received assistance. That's according to records kept by the Department of…
To keep the conversation about the Science Debate 2008 going, I decided to post, one per day, my ideas for potential questions to be asked at such a debate. The questions are far too long, though, consisting more of my musings than real questions that can be asked on TV (or radio or online,…
Note: This is the beginning of a multi-part series on agricultural education, the farming demographic crisis and the question of who will grow our food - what the problems are, how we will find new farmers, how they will be trained. To me, this is one of the most urgent questions of our time. A…