Study: Air Fresherners not good for you. Gee, ya think?

It must have been a slow news day over at MSN because they headlined a story that was pegged to a study published in 2005 (as far as I can tell). Anyway, the point of the article was that air fresheners aren't good for you. Hopefully this isn't a revelation for anyone (You mean that pumping out volatile chemicals into my closed room isn't good for me? Shocking!). Let's list a couple of the chemicals released from air fresheners (gel, liquid, spray, scented candles, incense)

VOCs (Volatile Organic Compounds). Health Effects From the EPA:

Eye, nose, and throat irritation; headaches, loss of coordination, nausea; damage to liver, kidney, and central nervous system. Some organics can cause cancer in animals; some are suspected or known to cause cancer in humans. Key signs or symptoms associated with exposure to VOCs include conjunctival irritation, nose and throat discomfort, headache, allergic skin reaction, dyspnea, declines in serum cholinesterase levels, nausea, emesis, epistaxis, fatigue, dizziness.

Various allergens, including terpenes like limonene (give a nice fresh/citrus scent)

Benzene (known human carcinogen - very small cancer risk at the levels for most air fresheners, but it will still attack your bone marrow)

Styrene (long term exposure leads to thinking problems and other effects on the central nervous system)

Diethyl Phthalate (unless you're using incense, you'd get a lot more from your cosmetics and personal car products)

Toluene (headaches, sleepiness, dexterity, memory, other narcotic effects, eye/nose watering)

Formaldehyde (damage to the nasal tissue, at increasing levels dizziness, altered breathing,...etc)

VOCs and benzene are over some countries' limits but most of the others are not. Read this review for a good overview of what we know - and don't - about air fresheners. Even for the chemicals under the health limits, it seems a bit silly to me to be paying to put these chemicals in your house.

Want your house to smell better? Open some windows. Clean. Then bake an apple pie. I'm serious.

PS The study they pegged it too doesn't have a whole lot to convince even though the conclusion is probably correct. They asked people who have asthma or other breathing difficulties if they had trouble breathing after being around an air freshener. That seems like a bucket load of bias there.

More like this

A recent study of air quality around unconventional oil and gas extraction sites — more commonly referred to as fracking — found high levels of benzene, hydrogen sulfide and formaldehyde, all of which pose risks to human health. But what makes this study particularly interesting is that the air…
by Eileen Senn, MS It seems obvious to many that respirators are needed to protect cleanup workers in the Gulf from inhaling air contaminants that are making some sick now and may make many more chronically ill in the future. I will describe a combination of political and scientific issues…
Several years ago as a young graduate student I was privy to gossip about a supposed site near Puerto Rico where pharmaceutical waste was dumped in the ocean. A senior scientist in my field told me that antibiotics in the waste killed off most of the natural microbes occurring in the water column…
By Elizabeth Grossman Expressions of concern for oil spill response workers' health and safety grew this past week as reports arrived by way of the Louisiana Environmental Action Network that BP was denying workers' requests for respirators. On June 4th, the Wall Street Journal reported that…

Thank you for posting this information, which is not new to us as you note, but seems to be to many. Just take a look at the air freshener section in your local discount store. Somebody must be paying good money to fill their home with carcinogens. Thankfully there was nothing more pressing in the news today!

In case anyone questions our concern, afterall, homes may smell "better" after using these. There are two primary ways in which air fresheners work. They either line your nasal passages with an oil - so you can't smell, or they release a nerve deadening agent - so you can't smell. Feel fresh!

Thanks for raising awareness!

Lynne Eldridge MD
Author, "Avoiding Cancer One Day At A Time: Practical Advice for Preventing Cancer"