Politico.com's massive and multiple ethical fail.

Yesterday, I had to modify a post on this blog shortly after publishing it. I had quoted material from a Politico.com story, and it turned out that Politico had made a very large error. Georgia Rep. Phil Gingery had given them a quote that was highly critical of Rush Limbaugh, and they somehow or another managed to attribute that quote to Rep. Tom Price instead.

Not only did they get the quote wrong in the article, they also apparently told Rush that Tom Price was talking about him. Here's a paragraph from the original version of the Politico article in question:

Asked to respond to Price, Limbaugh, in an email to Politico, wrote: "I don't know Tom Price. I'm sure he is doing his best but it does not appear to be good enough. He may not have noticed that the number of Republican colleagues he has in the House has dwindled. And they will dwindle more if he and his friends don't show more leadership and effectiveness in battling the most left-wing agenda in modern history. And they won't continue to lose because of me, but because of their relationship with the grassroots, which is hurting. Conservatives want leadership from those who claim to represent them. And we'll know it when we see it."

I'd love to give you a link to that particular quote on the Politico site, but I can't, because they seem to have dropped it down the memory hole. So you'll have to settle for this link to the original article, instead. When Politico first updated their article after being informed of their error, they changed the paragraph above to the version that you see on their page right now:

Asked to respond to Gingrey, Limbaugh, in an email to Politico, wrote: "I'm sure he is doing his best but it does not appear to be good enough. He may not have noticed that the number of Republican colleagues he has in the House has dwindled. And they will dwindle more if he and his friends don't show more leadership and effectiveness in battling the most left-wing agenda in modern history. And they won't continue to lose because of me, but because of their relationship with the grassroots, which is hurting. Conservatives want leadership from those who claim to represent them. And we'll know it when we see it."

Notice the two changes. They changed "asked to respond to Price" to "asked to respond to Gingrey", and they excised the part of the Limbaugh quote ("I don't know Tom Price") that makes it clear that they had, in fact, informed Rush that the culprit was Price.

This morning, in my RSS feed, I found another version of the Politico article. This particular version has a new title (Limbaugh takes a hit from Gingrey). That makes three different headlines that have been used for this particular piece. In addition to the change at the top, they also made another change at the bottom - one that shows a distinct lack of commitment to basic ethics.

When they changed the original article, they appended the following note to the bottom of the story:

Editor's note: An earlier version of this story incorrectly identified the GOP member as Rep. Tom Price. Politico regrets the error.

This morning's version omits even that somewhat incomplete mea culpa. In the rapidly changing world we believe in, it's nice to know that someone still believes that mistakes can be erased that easily.

Tags

More like this

The LA Times has a story about some religious right leaders pushing for gays to be purged from the Republican Party. In the wake of the Foley scandal, there are increasing calls to get gay people out of the party entirely. "The big-tent strategy could ultimately spell doom for the Republican Party…
One of the things to remember about the Tea Party Uruk-hai who run the Republican Party make up the shock troops of the GOP is that they were manufactured--just like the orcs in the Lord of the Rings. Comrade Driftglass explains: Conservatives built this monster. It didn't just wander out of the…
I was a graduate student in Harvard’s Anthropology Department, which meant I had no funding. I was in the final writing stage of my thesis, and the problem I had was that teaching interesting biological anthropology (which I could do full time if I wanted) was too distracting from the mundane yet…
As incredible as it seems, there are still those among us who think it clever and above it all to say that in America there is only the Republicrat Party. If you're one of those people who persist in saying that there is no difference between the parties, I would urge you to read this article from…

This is disappoining. Politico should both be smarter than this and have better ethics. When anyone does this it reflects far more poorly on whoever does it than if they simply come out and say what they did and note how it was wrong. Sigh.