Greatest Physicists #6 - Ernest Rutherford

#6 - Ernest Rutherford


The New Zealand physicist Ernest Rutherford was an incubator of genius, and a genius himself. His position on this list is probably a little unorthodox as he wasn't a very flashy scientist and he wasn't a theoretical wizard. He just happened to be a surpassingly great physicist anyway.

When Rutherford started his work in the late 1800s, modern physics was still quite new. Classical mechanics had been fleshed out reasonably well, but relativity and quantum mechanics didn't exist, and the world of the microscopic was very poorly understood. The very concept that there were such a thing as atoms wasn't entirely without controversy. The structure of atoms was something not far removed from blind conjecture.

The first steps toward understanding came from the discovery and subsequent study of radioactivity. These little bits of atoms provided the clues which helped to push back the darkness of the interior of the atom. Rutherford was at the forefront of this effort, describing and naming alpha and beta radiation, and making the discovery of radioactive half-life.

Rutherford is best known for his direction and supervision of the Geiger-Marsden experiment, which is certainly one of the most beautiful experiments in physics. He fired alpha particles at gold atoms and by their scattering was able to determine that the mass of the atom was overwhelmingly concentrated in a tiny central nucleus. It's both amazing for its elegance and the fact that it presaged quantum mechanics in an unexpected way. Classically, the behavior of particles scattering off of other particles is governed by a wholly different set of rules than it is in quantum mechanics. The classical rules for scattering are totally wrong at the subatomic level. But in an amazing coincidence, the quantum rules and classical rules happen to give the same answer for coulomb scattering off a nucleus. If it hadn't, Rutherford's experiment might well have been misinterpreted and subatomic physics would have probably been set back by years.

He hypothesized the existence of the neutron, and ran the institute where the neutron was discovered and the atom was first split. He was the first man in history to successfully perform alchemy. Well, nuclear transmutation of one element to another anyway.

So many things we take for granted as common and easy knowledge were first brought to light by Rutherford and his group. It's hard to contribute more to physics than that.

Honorable Mention: Niels Bohr, for similar reasons.

The list so far (click the category name for links):
6. Rutherford
7. Schrodinger
8. Dirac
9. Thomson
10. Pauli


More like this

Two chapters of the book-in-progress will be devoted to the development of the modern understanding of the atom. One of these is about the Bohr model, which turned 100 this year, but Bohr's model would not have been possible without an earlier experiment. The actual experiment was done by Ernest…
The eighth of the Top Eleven is an experiment by the man who set the gold standard for arrogance in physics. Who: Ernest Rutherford (1871-1937), a New Zealand-born physicist who famously declared "In science, there is only physics. All the rest is stamp collecting." He was awarded the Nobel Prize…
#2 - Albert Einstein Einstein. When a person's name and photograph are both literal synonyms for genius, it's a pretty good sign they're among the greatest of the greats. But even if Einstein had not become the popular legend which lives on to this day, he'd still tower above the science of…
The following is the approximate text of the talk I gave at TED@NYC last night. Approximate, because I'm somewhat prone to ad-libbing when speaking, and may have changed a few things here and there. I don't really know, because I'm scheduling this post on Tuesday morning, before the actual event,…

Yay Rutherford!

I was hoping Rutherford would get a mention. We Kiwi's are kinda predatory when one of our number does anything of international significance. But Rutherford is a special case. A Kiwi founded the science for the splitting of the atom, and yet New Zealand is one of the few developed countries in the world to shun the nuclear arms race.

I think I can be excused for taking a tiny bit of national pride in that. :P

A good choice, because experimental physics usually gets short shrift in such lists and Rutherford contributed as much by the way he ran his lab (and who he trained and hosted as visitors) as he did by his own work as both an experimentalist and theorist.

One thing you didn't point out, however, was that Rutherford's explanation of the Geiger and Marsden experiment in terms of "Rutherford scattering" was published 2 years after the experiment itself was published.

I tend to be a bit stronger on the controversial standing of the atom as a real object circa 1900. After all, Boltzman's suicide is attributed both to his manic depression and to the lack of acceptance of his vision of matter as atoms in motion. Einstein's 1905 paper about Brownian motion is counted as part of the "miracle year" because it connected atoms to the observable world. Transmutation also played a big role in making atoms real.

By CCPhysicist (not verified) on 09 Oct 2008 #permalink

There's an interesting anecdote about Rutherford's lab.

A young Pyotr Kapitsa (a Nobel Prize winner) wanted to work in Rutherford's lab, but at first Rutherford refused to admit him. Then Kapitsa asked what was a usual error margin in Rutherford's lab. Bewildered Rutherford answerd "About 3%".

Kapitsa answered: "There's 30 scientists employed in your lab. So with your precision you won't even notice me!".

And Kapitsa was admitted.

By Alex Besogonov (not verified) on 11 Oct 2008 #permalink

Not to quibble about what is clearly a matter of opinion, but I'd think that Bohr would easily make top 10.

By B McManus (not verified) on 29 Oct 2008 #permalink

my lol poo

By Anonymous (not verified) on 17 Apr 2012 #permalink