NCAA athletic moves

Interesting IHE article on NCAA problems and how it is, apparently, all the faculties' fault
Of course.

An interesting point in the comments is that anything goes, as long as the football team wins (or basketball or whatevah).
But, in the nature of the game, precisely half the teams lose each time. Which seems to be a guaranteed recipe for frustration of collegieate athletics.
Now this is partly circumvented by, for example, in football having 3 games against lower division teams for "warm-up", with near 100% certainty of victory. In which case the average football team playing 12 games would expect to perform at the 8-4/7-5 level, in division I-AAA football or however many "A"s the NCAA awards the top division (why can't it just be division 1, 2, 3 etc?)

So... you'd expect random games to give a nice broad spread from 11-1 to 4-8 as typical "average" performances for a team which plays 3 warmup games and 9 real games.
The lower division teams, would have the same spread but centered at 5-7 records because they accept 1-2 games each year against a much better team from a higher division.

So, no matter what we do, college atheltics supporters will never be happy because on average most teams will perform below the level they expect their team to perform at.


More like this

Inside Higher Ed today offers another hand-wringing piece about the problem of college athletics, this time from the president of Augustana College in Illinois. It's a particularly maddening example of the form, doing a lovely job of running down NCAA Division I schools in comparison to Division…
Over at Inside Higher Ed, they have a piece looking at the state of college football as we enter bowl season. This is dominated by two large tables of numbers, one good, and one bad. The first table is the good one, as it explains why the college football "championship" is so messed up. It lists…
This past weekend, I ended up hearing sports-radio pinheads holding forth proudly about their ignorance of college basketball. The justification for this is that "the regular season doesn't matter," since the NCAA tournament is single-elimination, and lesser-known teams keep ending up making big…
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach en:Joe Paterno on the sideline during warmups prior to the 2006 Homecoming game versus the University of Illinois on Friday, October 20, 2006. Joe Paterno at Penn State was one of the most successful, and controversial, football coaches at the University level…