Conscious vegetables, thoughtless adolescents, and the Stroop Effect: Quick links from around the Web

  • The blogosphere is abuzz with discussion of a new experiment purporting to show brain activity in a woman who was in a "persistent vegetative state." For a good summary of the experiment, visit Mind Hacks. Then take a look at Brain Ethics' analysis. I think the best analysis comes from ScienceBlogs' own Jake at Pure Pedantry. The upshot: The "persistent vegetative state" was probably misdiagnosed. FMRI imaging can help diagnose true cases of persistent vegetative state.
  • There's a nice article at New Scientist discussing decision-making in adolescents. Again fMRI was used to record brain activity as both teens and adults were asked to explain their decision-making processes. Adolescents tended to rely more on the superior temporal sulcus, while adults used the prefrontal cortex. Since the STS isn't really equipped to handle complex social decisions, teens tend to be more self-centered, while adults take the impact on others into account.
  • MindBlog has a fascinating report on just how little intervention is necessary to reduce achievement gaps due to racial stereotyping,
  • Finally, idiolect has found a tantalizing abstract of a study claiming to show that driving ability is predicted by performance on the Stroop task.
Tags

More like this

There are 13 new articles in PLoS ONE today. As always, you should rate the articles, post notes and comments and send trackbacks when you blog about the papers. You can now also easily place articles on various social services (CiteULike, Connotea, Stumbleupon, Facebook and Digg) with just one…
Normal children - and adult patients with frontal damage - frequently have difficulty changing their responses to stimuli when the correct response changes. This difficulty is often considered an inability to switch between rules, but might result not so much from an inability to switch as from an…
Multitasking refers to the simultaneous performance of two or more tasks, switching back and forth between different tasks, or performing a number of different tasks in quick succession. It consists of two complementary stages: goal-shifting, in which one decides to divert their attention from one…
There are a few fascinating papers to come out recently that I won't have time to cover in detail, but which people may find interesting. References and abstracts after the jump: Watson & Strayer (2010). Supertaskers: Profiles in extraordinary multitasking ability. Psychon Bull Rev. Abstract…

It would have been nice if they had presented some evidence suggesting that the adolescents were reasoning more poorly, or more slowly, or that their judgment was in some important qualitative way inferior than the adults'... but they didn't.

There seem to be a number of unquestioned assumptions in that article.

By Caledonian (not verified) on 13 Sep 2006 #permalink