Dumbest CME Question Ever

This was one of those snap quizzes, where you read an article, answer a
couple questions, and get 0.25 CME credits. It had to do with
biomarkers for cardiac risk.  After plowing through a ton of
obscure information about CRP, urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio, and
things like that, I get to the test questions:

65-year-old man with a history of diabetes, hypertension, and
dyslipidemia presents with chest pain. He is a nonsmoker. Which of the
following is not a contributing risk factor for the
development of cardiovascular disease in this patient?  ( class="cmetag">Required for credit)
  name="option-15343" type="radio"> Diabetes
  value="60890" name="option-15343" type="radio"> Smoking
  name="option-15343" type="radio"> Hypertension
  name="option-15343" type="radio"> Dyslipidemia

Gee, let's see...he's a nonsmoker.  Maybe smoking is not a
risk factor for him, do ya think?


More like this

I will never forget the very first patient history I ever took. Part of medical school training is they send you onto the wards to gather patient histories and physicals so you learn to gather information effectively as a clinician. My first patient history was on a woman about 35 years old on…
How do doctors decide what is healthy and unhealthy? Do they arbitrarily decide on risk factors to line their pockets - creating false epidemics as Sandy Szwarc at Junkfood Science suggests? Or, is there actually a science, called epidemiology, that is the basis for health recommendations? As I…
Yesterday I issued a challenge to naturopathic physicians to justify why they should be considered competent primary care physicians. The best and most comprehensive answer received so far is the one from "Mona". Here is my analysis. Her response, while not entirely "wrong", shows a frightening…
Orac has a post up on this new JAMA paper as well. He brings up some better examples than the one I gave: Does anyone in this day and age still believe that smoking doesn't cause lung cancer? The epidemiological evidence of the association is bulletproof. However, the majority of smokers don't…

It doesn't say he was the one who was smoking--what if second-hand smoke is a risk factor? It's always possible to over-think these things, tho.

By whomever1 (not verified) on 21 Dec 2006 #permalink

No kidding. I'm _still_ trying to work out what it has to do with Coronal Mass Ejections.

secondhand smoke? No-no.

He was just a victim of involuntary smoking.

By doctorgoo (not verified) on 22 Dec 2006 #permalink

This reminds me of some of the questions on the multi-state legal ethics exam. There were some substantive technical questions that addressed important information, but some were like this:

"A new client gives you a $25,000 retainer check. You
(a) use it to buy tickets to Vegas for you and your girlfried, and expect to make up the difference at the blackjack table.
(b) cash the check and put the cash in a shoebox under your desk.
(c) deposit it in an interest-bearing bank escrow account for the benefit of your client.
(d) use it to play the penny stock market, and keep the profits for yourself.

By PhysioProf (not verified) on 23 Dec 2006 #permalink