Freud Was Wrong

Sigmund Freud was right about a lot of things, but he also was wrong
about a lot of
things.  For example, he thought that there were only two
fundamental motivations: sex and aggression.  Bloggers know
better, as this xkcd panel illustrates...


href="http://xkcd.com/386/">i-0c038bd04fa75c63b32d6d4c2b790e2e-duty_calls.png



(I know href="http://scienceblogs.com/evolvingthoughts/2008/02/why_i_never_sleep.php">my
colleague already posted this, but I couldn't resist putting
this twist on it.)


Tags

More like this

Smaller chimps may use grooming rather than aggression as a means to rise in their social hierarchy: The finding was gleaned from 10 years of observing dominant male chimpanzees in Gombe National Park, Tanzania, looking at behaviors they used to compete for alpha male status relative to their size…
I know many of you are trembling in anticipation: "Did I make it this year?". Well, it's like the Oscars - the Academy Awards are kept tightly under wraps until the moment the envelope is opened. The list of entries was long, and full of excellent posts - this was hard to judge! And, Jennifer Rohn…
SciCurious has written an interesting post about Sigmund Freud's experiments with cocaine. Freud, the father of psychoanalysis, was also a pioneer of psychopharmacology; as well as being one of the first to scientifically investigate the properties and effects of cocaine, he also played a key role…
This is an image of a human brain.  It is constructed using an imaging method known as diffusion spectrum imaging.  The technique has been discussed at href="http://scienceblogs.com/neurophilosophy/2008/07/hi_res_brain_topology_map.php">Neurophilosophy and href="http://anthropology.net/2008…

If it's the internet, it's already sex and aggression.

And, it's YOU!

By Spelling Police (not verified) on 26 Feb 2008 #permalink

No serious person believes anything Freud came up with regarding sexuality. Thoroughly unscientific and disrespectful to the human condition.

More than anything else Freud was a radical idealist. It is undeniable that he was wrong about many psychological principles, yet his claims managed to break a stagnant mindset in the field as a whole. Perhaps his reasoning and scientific method lack legitimacy, but the men and women who have based a lifetime of work to disprove his claims have furthered psychology at a remarkable pace. It is possible to argue that Freud is the father of modern psychology. Freud has impacted all of our lives in a positive manner despite his lack of authentic research.

By Christian (not verified) on 29 Nov 2011 #permalink