PETM, Volcanoes, and #18 in 25 Things You Should Know


Approximately 55 million years ago it was very bad to be a deep-sea animal. First the ocean temperature was rising. At the surface, temperatures rose anywhere from 5-10 degrees and in the deep around 5 degrees. The chemistry of the water also changed significantly. Oxygen became depleted. The ocean became more acidic. Global currents were altered such that deep-water upwelled in the Northern Hemisphere instead of the Southern for ~100,000 years.

This event is used to mark the end of the Paleocene and the start of the Eocene and thus the event is called the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum. A old instructor of mine use to refer to it as the P.E. S*&^ Storm. I digress but you get the point.


The warmer, hypoxic, acidic ocean was essentially an inhospitable place leading to a mass extinction event. 30-40% of calcareous benthic forams went extinct. Many other groups like gastropods are also hypothesized to went extinct. In general, the PETM was considered a resetting of the deep-sea fauna especially for those organisms possessing calcareous shells which don't fair well under increased acidity. However, some groups such as isopods are predicted to have made it through the PETM. Oh yeah, mammals died off too.

Another way to grasp the PETM event is by looking at C-13:C-12.  It appears that a few metabolic enzymes, but not all, in organisms prefer C-12 to C-13.  The reason appears to be that C-12 is slightly more energetic and thus more likely to react.  Thus organisms are differentially made up of Carbon-12 as opposed to Carbon-13.  If more phytoplankton growth then theC-12 decreases.  Less C-12 indicates less photosynthesis and production.  Thus shells below made up of of calcium carbonate formed in high C-12 waters would also high C-12 and low C-13:C-12.  A sample of marine sediments from the PETM event with the tons of foram shells would give an indication of the the phytoplankton production at this point.  Samples from the PETM have very high levels of C-12.  But are far greater than that would be expected just from a stop of all photosynthetic activity.  Even if you burned every living thing on the planet, returning on the 12C, it would only be 1/3 that of the  PETM13C:12C ratio. 

What caused the PETM and the sudden rise in C-12? Greenhouse gases other than carbon dioxide. It has been argued that methane, a far more effective greenhouse gas, was released into the atmosphere causing the PETM. It is proposed that the methane source was ice in deep seafloor sediments one of the only massive pools of light carbon (C-12), the methane burp hypothesis.  In once scenario, erosion or seismic activity along the continental margin may have allowed methane to escape from gas reservoirs.  In an other, a gradual surface change in temperature lead to a snowball effct by leading to a thermal dissociation of methane hydrate. However, a very recent study in Science indicates that the PETM may be linked to a massive volcanic eruptions that pushed Greenland and northwest Europe apart to create the North Atlantic Ocean.

"That prehistoric volcanic activity released more than 2000 gigatonnes (billion metric tons) of carbon into the oceans and atmosphere in the form of methane and carbon dioxide - two potent greenhouse gases," said Michael Storey of Roskilde University in Denmark, the study's lead author. "The carbon probably came from the heating of earlier deposits of decayed organic matter - similar to deposits in the Atlantic and North Sea we tap today for oil and gas."

You can have some confidence in the dating of the ash layer as...

That dating method, performed in labs at the three universities, renders precise ages in geological time frames, based on known decay rates of potassium to argon trapped in the volcanic material.

Foram image from

More like this

Well, the good news is a recent finding of 740,000 year old permafrost in the Canadian arctic. What this suggests is that the permafrost may be more resilient than previously thought. If this ice is 740Kyr old, then it did not melt during the last three inter-glacial cycles. The peak warmth of…
In the last 10 years, the average temperature of the earth as increased by 0.75 degrees Celsius. In less you have not read a newspaper or watched the news in the last 15 years, you would know that a majority of scientists have linked this to increasing C02 emissions from the burning of fossil…
If predicting climate trends was as easy as predicting the reaction of global warming pseudoskeptics there wouldn't be any deniers left. When I came across a new study in Nature Geoscience on the cause of the massive shift in the climate 55 million years ago, my first reaction was, "How long will…
As I browsed the new papers published this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, I was brought up short by this frolicsome picture. It's a nice example of the visual display of information done right. It shows the spread of primates 55 million years ago across the Northern…

can you elaborate/clarify how the 12C:13C ratio helps understand the PETM extinctions?

Another way to grasp the PETM extinction event is by looking at 13C:12C. Organisms are differentially made up of Carbon-12 as opposed to Carbon-13. Increases in biological activity requiring more 12C thus inrease the 13C:12C ratio. If you burned every living thing on the planet, returning on the 12C, it would only be 1/3 that of the PETM13C:12C ratio.