Good article on Rachel Carson and DDT in Discover

Discover has a good article on Rachel Carson, DDT and malaria. Unlike many other recently published articles (e.g. the New York Times) it gets the science right:

But elsewhere, the picture is murkier. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), over 500 million cases of malaria occur each year, resulting in an estimated 1 million deaths. Most of these cases of illness and mortality occur in sub-Saharan Africa. But no one can say whether malaria rates have increased or declined in Africa as a whole in recent decades because of difficulties in collecting data, says Valentina Buj, public-health officer for the WHO's Global Malaria Programme in Geneva. Some countries do not track whether DDT has been used to combat malaria. "Given the wide variation in the transmission of the disease--endemic areas, areas of low endemicity, hyperendemic areas, and sometimes these strata all occurring in the same country--we prefer to look at each country separately without aggregates over the entire continent," Buj says.

The confusion is also reflected by the fact that in the past year officials at the WHO have issued contradictory directives on the use of DDT to fight malaria. On September 15, 2006, Arata Kochi, the head of the Global Malaria Programme, announced at a news conference in Washington, D.C., that DDT posed no health risk when sprayed in small quantities on the inside walls of houses, and he called for an expansion of its use to combat the mosquito-borne disease. Then on May 3, 2007, Maria Neira, director of the WHO's public-health and environment department, said at a Dakar, Senegal, meeting of the ratifiers of the Stockholm Convention--an international treaty that went into effect in 2004 that controls the use of persistent organic pollutants like DDT--that the WHO's goal was to reduce the use of DDT and eventually eliminate it.

Lost in all the hullabaloo is the fact that DDT has never been completely banned for use in public-health measures. The Stockholm Convention defines disease control as an "acceptable use" for DDT, and 13 countries in Africa and Asia have registered their intention to use it as such.

Hat tip: Ed Darrell

Tags

More like this

The Washington Post reports: Long-lasting, insecticide-treated mosquito nets should be distributed free, rapidly and widely in malaria-endemic areas, World Health Organization officials said here Thursday, setting new guidelines for fighting the mosquito-borne disease around the globe. For years, a…
Yes, the DDT ban myth is back, this time in "DDT Returns" by Apoorva Mandavilli that reads like a press release by DDT advocacy group Africa Fighting Malaria. It's in Nature Medicine of all places and is subscription only, but because I'll be quoting the bits that are wrong or misleading you'll see…
A NY Times article on Arata Kochi, new chief of the World Health Organization's global malaria program wrongly stated that DDT was banned and had to be corrected: An article in Science Times on Tuesday, profiling Dr. Arata Kochi, the new chief of the World Health Organization's campaign against…
The New York Times reports: Dr. Kochi said the most substantive change in the W.H.O.'s guidelines on the use of insecticides would extend the reach of the strategy. Until now, the agency had recommended indoor spraying of insecticides in areas of seasonal or episodic transmission of malaria, but it…

500 million cases of malaria occur each year?

So, in less than two years everybody in the entire African continent has contracted malaria? In 12-13 years the whole world has got the thing?

I must have missed something.