Stephen Fenech and The Daily Telegraph promote Q-link quackery

The Q-link is a device that purports to protect you from radiation from mobile phones using "A coil connected to nothing". Ben Goldacre and Orac have comprehensively debunked Q-link's claims.

Yesterday Sydney's Daily Telegraph published a story promoting Q-link (the on-line version has now vanished) by Stephen Fenech, their technology writer. Fenech's story read like an advertisement for Q-link, with their claims for the benefits of the product presented as factual and including the url of their website where you could buy one.

That's bad enough, but it also turns out that he's done this before and that Fenech's brother is paid to promote Q-link.

Update: Here's Today Show technology editor Charlie Brown promoting the Q-Link on the Today Show.

Your go to blog for coverage of this whole sordid affair is A Drunken Madman. See also posts by Dan's Data, Chrys Stevenson and Jeremy Sear.

More like this

Ben Goldacre at Bad Science is leading the way on opposing this new absurdity of "electric smog", and one of it's leading proponents in Britain, Julia Stephenson. It's really too easy. Remember the crank HOWTO? Well, she's just about a perfect example. It all started when she got wifi in her…
The Independent has yet another hysterical article about the potential link between cell phones and brain cancer. And I've been asked, what are we seeing here? Is this the early reporting of a potential public health threat? Or is it just more nonsense from a newspaper that wouldn't know good…
So Leonardo DiCaprio is picking up where Al Gore left off in the battle to keep Earth habitable. Is this a good thing? Set aside, for the purposes of this discussion, any misgivings you might have about DiCaprio's acting prowess or lack thereof. They guy has a certain ineffable quality that has…
If you're at all familiar with Ben Goldacre's Bad Science blog and Guardian column, you'll have some idea of what his talk was about - debunking nutritionists, the multi-billion dollar industry nutritional supplement industry they have built, and the overblown claims about the benefits of various…

Well, kudos to Daily Telegraph for pulling it anyway. Someone should really get a journalist black list going.

Someone should really get a journalist black list going.

A white list would be more efficient.

A Naturopathic physician?

Dunc: with "more efficient" you mean "shorter", right? ;-)

See update for a video of a clueless "technology editor" promoting the Q-Link on the Today Show.

By Tim Lambert (not verified) on 05 Nov 2010 #permalink

Don't tell me, let me guess.

The Q in Q-link stands for ta daaaa! Quantum.

It does, doesn't it. (I've read enough back pages of New Scientist to see this coming.)

Hmm, not sure how y'all'd phrase this in the Commonwealth countries, but in America the saying is, You can't make this shit up!

Hey, with actual serious health and fittness stores flogging those stupid magnetic 'balance' bracelets for $50 a pop these days we can hardly be surprised by this.

What? You're saying that magnetic balance bracelets and the Q-link device don't work?! Now what am I supposed to do with all these stupid things?

According to Wikipedia, Charlie Brown and Stephen Fenech both appear as regular guests on the Kerri-Anne show, which follows on the heels of the Today show as "featured" above.

Embarrassing to hear Brown dissembling about this device for whatever reasons. Either it's killing him to plug something he's been asked to that's obviously a scam, or he's bashful that he hasn't done his homework on it.

Everyone feel free to let the ACCC know about this rubbish ...

By Donkeyotee (not verified) on 06 Nov 2010 #permalink

Media Watch will be doing a story on this tonight.

According to Media Watch Mario boosts this item because he believes in it not because he is paid for it.

Heh.

Perhaps Mario Fenech didn't start using the Qlink early enough, and fried his brain...

By Bernard J. (not verified) on 09 Nov 2010 #permalink