Volokh on Accusations of Moral Relativism

Eugene Volokh is guest-blogging for Glenn Reynolds on MSNBC and has written an excellent essay on the commonly-heard accusation that liberals exhibit moral relativism. Very well analyzed and fair-minded.

More like this

Dale Carpenter, one of the most articulate defenders of gay marriage, is guest-blogging at the Volokh Conspiracy this week, after gay marriage opponent Maggie Gallagher blogged there a couple weeks ago. Carpenter is doing an excellent job of rebutting Gallagher's claims and the arguments offered by…
Do you remember the old Five-Year Plans ('Petoletka') in the communist countries? Well, five years is far too long for the ADHD world of the 21st century, not to mention the hyperspeed of the Internet and the Blogosphere. So, I decided to try organizing my blogging in Five-Day Plans. What do you…
Glenn Reynolds declares that a private listserv run by Ezra Klein is a "scandal". Which is interesting, because I first ran into Glenn Reynolds on a private listserv run by Eugene Volokh. The members included pro-gun law professors like Reynolds, an NRA staffer and at least one journalist. I do not…
Lott has a long message at his website where he discusses Mary Rosh and argues that when he claimed that he had "not participated in the firearms discussion group nor in the apparent online newsgroup discussions", he was not lying: Another misunderstanding in the media is that I was lying as…

I often hear the moral relavist cliche get thrown around when talking about liberals, but I rarely hear any specific examples of when it is practiced.

On the other hand, christian conservatives use moral relativism all the time. Whenever criticisms of the bible are thrown at them, specifically the cruel punishments handed out in the old testament and the endorsement of slavery that is spread throughout the bible, apologists often use the "different culture" excuse. If that's not moral relativism, I don't know what is.

By Matthew Phillips (not verified) on 26 Sep 2004 #permalink

I used to be a regular reader of the Volokh Conspiracy, though my attention has lately migrated elsewhere, and I respect Mr. Volokh's intellect more than most.

But...

I have a hard time taking seriously anyone who sees the political landscape in the empty terms *liberal* and *conservative.* Too many have bought into the dumbing-down of the language in recent years, and this distinction is right in the superficiality vortex that brought us "the axis of evil."

The thing that kills me -- every damn day -- is that people will vote for George Bush because he doesn't come off sounding *too* smart, and they connect with him because of that. I just don't know how you fight that.

E