Mr. Sandefur has a thorough fisking of a law review article advocating the teaching of ID as constitutional at the Panda's Thumb. Travel hither and read.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
The Panda's Thumb currently features two essays thoroughly fisking attempts by pro-ID pundits to defend ID. The first post, by Timothy Sandefur, deals with an article from Hugh Hewitt, the religious right talk show host (and ironically, Sandefur's con law professor in law school). The second, by…
Timothy Sandefur has an excellent post at the Panda's Thumb fisking Frank Beckwith's article in Legal Times concerning the Cobb County decision. The crux of Beckwith's argument is that the ruling "presents a Catch-22 that makes it nearly impossible for religious citizens to remedy public policies…
Given the proceedings in Dover, the timing of this could not be better. Matt Brauer, Barbara Forrest and Steven Gey have written what is probably the most thorough review of the question of ID and whether teaching it in schools violates the establishment clause. The resulting article, published in…
Reed Cartwright thoroughly demolishes the DI's spin concerning the Cobb County case in this post at the Panda's Thumb. Timothy Sandefur continues the fisking in this post, where he points out that all the talk of "critical thinking" on the part of the ID advocates is disingenuous nonsense. Nice…
Thither.